Reference
Six letters, annotated: a request, an appeal, a complaint, a proposal, a reference and instructions
One finished piece of each kind, written from this manual's fictional cases and marked up so each part is labeled on the page: where the ask sits, what the reference line does, what the facts are doing, and what was left out.
Each piece below is finished: it could be sent as written, if the people and the facts were real. They are not. Every person, business, office, number and address on this page is fictional, drawn from the five cases this manual uses, and each piece is labeled. The highlighted lines are the ones that carry the piece. The notes under a line say what it is doing, and sometimes what was left out and why.
Read the one that matches what you are writing, then the chapter it comes from. To borrow a sentence rather than a whole letter, use Sentences that do a job.
LimitsThese are shapes to adapt, not forms to copy. If the office you are writing to provides a form or a portal, its form overrides every shape here: fill in its boxes, put your ask in the first one, and attach your letter. None of these pieces is legal advice. Nothing on this page says whether a request will be granted, an appeal will succeed, a fee was charged lawfully or a reference is safe to send; the office that decides, a state agency or a lawyer answers those. Dates inside the pieces belong to the fictional cases. For your own deadline, the letter or notice you received governs your case.
| Piece | Reader | The ask | Length, in words |
| A request (Marisol Chen) | Her plant manager | Move three closing shifts a week to the opening shift from a set date, and answer by a set date | 217 |
| An appeal (Walt Osei) | The health plan's appeals unit | Reverse a denial of a claim the plan called "not medically necessary" | 221 |
| A complaint (Corinne Vasquez) | Her property manager | Remove a $125 late fee and send a corrected ledger by a set date | 209 |
| A proposal (Pine Street garden group) | A city land commission (fictional), at its November meeting | Adopt a motion giving permission to garden a vacant city lot for one season | 236 |
| A reference (Theo Brandt) | A hiring manager he has not met | Weigh a coworker's application on what he saw her do, dated | 198 |
| Instructions (Marisol Chen) | A new hire on the opening shift | Open the plant in order, and stop at the two warnings | 478 |
Lengths are counted on the piece itself, without the notes. None of the six runs past one page.
Five of the six put the ask in the first paragraph. That is the plain-language rule, not a trick: Digital.gov's guide to organizing a document says to "Put the most important information at the beginning." Convention The reference letter puts the writer's relationship to the applicant there instead, because that is what its reader weighs first. In all six, every fact carries a date, every number sits next to the document it came from, and no sentence says what kind of person the reader is. That last rule is ours. Preference
A request: changing a work schedule
Marisol Chen is a shift supervisor at a plant bakery in Fresno, California. She works the closing shift, and her dialysis clinic's only open chair is at 3:00 p.m. three afternoons a week. The chapter behind this piece is Asking for something.
Fictional example
Marisol Chen, Valley Hearth Bakery and everyone named here are fictional. Known (from the case): she works the closing shift, 2:00 p.m. to 10:30 p.m. Her clinic's only open chair is at 3:00 p.m. on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays from Monday, January 4, 2027, and the clinic asks her to confirm by December 11. The opening shift runs 5:00 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Ruben Soto, who opens now, has said he would like closing shifts. Her manager is Dolores Ibarra. Assumed for this example: the wording, the copy to Human Resources and her reply date. Open: whether the bakery treats this as an accommodation, as leave or as an ordinary schedule change, and what paperwork follows. Valley Hearth's Human Resources office settles that, and if it has a form, this email becomes the attachment.
To: Dolores Ibarra, Plant Manager, Valley Hearth Bakery
Cc: Human Resources
Date: November 16, 2026
Subject: Request to move to opening shift Mon/Wed/Fri from January 4The subject line carries the ask and the start date, so Dolores can find it in her inbox a month from now.
Dear Dolores,
I am asking to work the opening shift (5:00 a.m. to 1:30 p.m.) on Mondays, Wednesdays and Fridays, starting Monday, January 4, 2027. Could you let me know by Friday, December 4?The ask in two sentences, with both dates in them. Dolores can say yes by replying with one word.
The reason is medical. I start dialysis on those three afternoons, and the clinic's only open chair is at 3:00 p.m. My closing shift (2:00 p.m. to 10:30 p.m.) overlaps it. The clinic needs my answer by December 11.One reason Dolores can act on, and the outside date that sets hers. Marisol names the treatment and the chair time because they fix the hours. Her diagnosis is not here, and nothing needs it to be.The email names no law. The EEOC's guidance says a person asking for an accommodation may use "plain English" and need not mention the ADA. Whether this is an accommodation under the ADA is a question for Human Resources or the EEOC, not for this email.
Two ways this could work:
1. Opening shift on Monday, Wednesday and Friday; closing shift on Tuesday and Thursday as now. This is the one I would prefer.
2. Opening shift all five days.Two options she could live with, and which one she prefers. Dolores picks rather than designs. Offering an option you would refuse invites the answer you do not want.
Ruben Soto, who opens now, has told me he would like closing shifts. You may want to ask him.Answers the first question Dolores would ask (who covers closing?) before she has to ask it. Marisol passes on what Ruben said and leaves the asking to Dolores.
If you need a note from my doctor confirming the treatment schedule, tell me and I will ask for one. If Human Resources has a form for this, please send it and I will return it within two working days.Offers documentation without volunteering records. The EEOC's guidance says an employer "may require only the documentation that is needed to establish" the disability and the need.
If I have not heard by then, I will stop by your office on Monday, December 7.What she will do next, and when. A plan, not a reproach, and still four days before the clinic's date.
Thank you,
Marisol Chen
Shift supervisor
(559) 555-0142
The guidance quoted in the notes is the EEOC's enforcement guidance on reasonable accommodation, issued October 17, 2002. The page itself notes that it predates the ADA Amendments Act of 2008. The same page says requests "do not need to be in writing"; Marisol writes hers anyway, because the email dates the request and records exactly what she asked for.
An appeal: a denied health plan claim
Walt Osei, 61, of Tucson, Arizona, had an MRI that his health plan then refused to pay for, in a letter dated October 2. He writes to the reason the plan gave and to nothing else. The chapter behind this piece is Appealing a decision, and the deadline counter counts the days on a letter like his.
Fictional example
Walt Osei, Saguaro Health Plan and everyone named here are fictional. Known (from the case): an MRI of his lower back on September 3, 2026, billed at $2,340; a denial dated October 2, 2026 giving the reason as "not medically necessary"; claim number SHP-2026-118842; member ID SHP-M-50318; Dr. Priya Nand ordered the MRI. Assumed for this example: the wording and the enclosures. Open: whether Saguaro is an employer plan or one he bought himself, which decides the route after an internal appeal. The plan's letters settle it.
His deadline comes from his own letter. If the appeal section gives 180 days, Walt counts them from the date printed on the letter, October 2, because he has not confirmed how the plan counts and that is the earlier date: 180 calendar days from October 2 is Wednesday, March 31, 2027. HealthCare.gov's page on internal appeals gives the published figure, to file "within 180 days (6 months) of receiving notice" that a claim was denied. That is a published figure, not a lookup for his case: the letter he received governs his case, and where the two differ, the plan that sent it is the authority. Nothing on this page says whether his appeal will succeed.
Walt Osei
1408 East Ocotillo Lane
Tucson, AZ 85719
520-555-0172
[the date it goes]The letter waits for Dr. Nand's letter, so it carries no date until the day it is mailed. A date earlier than the enclosure it describes would be the first thing a reviewer notices.
Appeals Unit
Saguaro Health Plan
[the appeals address printed on the October 2 letter]The appeals address from the denial letter, not the claims address on the member card. The two can differ, and the letter is the one that says where appeals go.
Member: Walt Osei
Member ID: SHP-M-50318
Claim number: SHP-2026-118842
Service: MRI, September 3, 2026, billed at $2,340
Decision: letter dated October 2, 2026A reference block above the greeting. HealthCare.gov says you can write to the insurer "with your name, claim number, and health insurance ID number." All three are here, so a clerk can pull the file before reading a sentence.
To the Appeals Unit:
I am appealing your decision of October 2, 2026 denying coverage for the MRI of my lower back on September 3, 2026, claim number SHP-2026-118842, and I am asking you to reverse it and cover the MRI because my doctor ordered it for the reasons her enclosed letter gives.The one sentence that does most of the work: the decision by its date, the claim number, the ask and the ground. A reviewer who stops here knows what to do.
Your letter gives one reason: that the MRI was "not medically necessary." This letter answers that reason.Writing to the stated ground. The denial named the reason; the appeal answers it and leaves out the rest of the history.
Dr. Priya Nand, my doctor, ordered the MRI. Her enclosed letter explains why she ordered it and answers the reason your letter gives.Whether the scan was necessary is a medical question, so the doctor's letter makes that case. Walt's letter says who ordered the scan and where her reasons are, and does not argue medicine himself.
Please reverse the decision on claim SHP-2026-118842 and send your decision to the address above. Please also send me a copy of the criteria or policy section you used to decide that the MRI was not medically necessary.The ask, said again where the letter ends. Asking for the criteria costs nothing; whether the plan has to send them is a question for the plan or the state insurance department.
If you need anything else to decide this appeal, please write to me at the address above or call 520-555-0172.
Sincerely,
Walt Osei
Enclosures:
1. Copy of the October 2, 2026 denial letter
2. Letter from Dr. Priya NandCopies, not originals, and only what bears on the stated reason: not the premium statements, not the history of his condition, not his phone notes.
The letter goes by a route that leaves a record. The Postal Service's page on extra services describes Certified Mail as "Prove you sent it" and listed it at $5.55, with a mailed Return Receipt at $4.65, when this manual read the page on 11/13/2026. Prices change; the page is the authority. What each record proves, and what it does not, is in Sending it, and after.
A complaint: a late fee charged in error
Corinne Vasquez rents a one-bedroom in Dayton, Ohio. Her management company posted a late fee on rent that cleared on the 1st, and her lease says rent is late after the 5th. The chapter behind this piece is Complaining so it gets fixed.
Fictional example
Corinne Vasquez, Brookside Management and everyone named here are fictional. Known (from the case): unit 2B, account 4471, rent of $1,040 a month. Her November rent cleared by bank transfer on Sunday, November 1, 2026, and a $125 late fee was posted to her ledger on Tuesday, November 3. Section 4 of her lease says rent is late after the 5th, but her copy is still in a box from her move. When she called the office on Wednesday, November 4, the front desk told her the fee was automatic and that the property manager can reverse fees. Assumed for this example: the wording. Open: why an automatic charge fired on a payment that cleared on the 1st (a posting date, a system setting, a clerk's entry). Brookside settles that, and Corinne does not need to know it to ask for the fee back.
To: Property manager, Brookside Management [the office email on my rent statement]
Date: Monday, November 9, 2026
Subject:
Account 4471: late fee charged in error, please removeThe account number first, then the fault, then the fix. Someone scanning a queue of messages can act on the subject line alone.
Hello,
Please remove the $125 late fee posted to account 4471 (Unit 2B) on November 3, 2026, and send me a corrected ledger by Monday, November 23.The fix as an amount and an action, both checkable when they arrive, with a date. She does not ask for an explanation or an apology: she asks for the two things that close the matter.
My November rent of $1,040 cleared my bank account by transfer on Sunday, November 1. Section 4 of my lease says rent is late after the 5th of the month. My copy of the lease is still packed from my move; I will send that page when I find it.
The dated fact, then the rule that binds the reader. She names the section but does not quote it, because she cannot check the words yet, and she says so rather than guessing.
When I called the office on November 4, the front desk told me the fee is charged automatically and that the property manager can reverse it. A payment that cleared on the 1st should not trigger it.
One line on the call, because it explains how the error happened and who can fix it, which is why the email goes to the property manager. She has only a first name for the person, so she leaves the name out of the email and keeps it in her log.
I have attached:
1. The page of my bank statement showing the November 1 transfer of $1,040 to Brookside Management, with the line marked.
2. A screenshot of my resident ledger showing the $125 fee posted November 3.
Copies, each with the line that matters marked, so nobody has to hunt.
If the fee is still on my ledger after November 23, I will write again, by email and by Certified Mail.The next step as a plan with a date, not a threat. Where a landlord dispute goes after the company is Learn Conflict Management's page on where to take a dispute.
Thank you,
Corinne Vasquez
Unit 2B, account 4471
937-555-0114
What the email leaves out is as deliberate as what it says: the months she paid on time, how the fee made her feel, and any guess at why the system charged it. Each would be true and none would help the person at the desk remove the fee. Whether the fee was allowed is a question about her lease and Ohio law that this page does not answer; the rungs above the company are in Where it goes next.
A proposal: one page for a commission
The Pine Street garden group is nine households in Portland, Maine, who want to garden on the vacant lot at 118 Pine Street. They need one page for the land commission's November meeting. The chapter behind this piece is Proposing something to a group.
Fictional example
The Pine Street garden group, the Portland land commission (a fictional body) and everyone named here are fictional. Known (from the case): nine households; the lot at 118 Pine Street; the commission meets Tuesday, November 24, 2026, and its agenda deadline is Tuesday, November 10; a $1,140 quote and a $260 estimate, with $1,400 pledged by the households; the contact is Ines Moreau. Assumed for this example: the wording, the build dates and the alternative. Open: whether the lot has a water connection and what the city requires in insurance. The water department and the city's risk management office settle those, and the page says they are open rather than hiding them. Whether the commission can grant the use itself is the clerk's to answer, from the commission's rules.
PINE STREET GARDEN GROUP
Proposal to the Portland land commission
For the meeting of Tuesday, November 24, 2026
Submitted November 6, 2026 (agenda deadline: Tuesday, November 10)
The meeting and the agenda deadline at the top. The agenda deadline is the real deadline: a page that misses it is not decided in November, however good it is.
MOTION
Grant the Pine Street garden group permission to use the city-owned lot at 118 Pine Street as a community garden from April 1 to October 31, 2027, on terms set by city staff, with the group paying all the costs listed below.A motion: one sentence, beginning with a verb, that the commission could adopt as written. The people who decide do not have to draft anything.
WHAT IT COSTS AND WHO PAYS
- Lumber and soil for nine raised beds: $1,140 (written quote, October 28, attached).
- Hand tools and hoses: $260 (our estimate, from store prices listed October 30).
- Paid by: the nine households, $1,400 pledged in writing (list attached).
- Cost to the city: none that we know of. Water and insurance are open; we have asked the water department and the risk management office.
Every figure has its source and its date beside it, and the pledges cover the total. The two unknowns are named as unknowns rather than left for a commissioner to find.
WHO DOES THE WORK
The group builds the beds on April 3 and 10, 2027, keeps the paths mowed, and removes everything by October 31, 2027. Contact: Ines Moreau, (207) 555-0163.
One named owner, not "the group." A commission can put a question to a person.
IF NOTHING IS DONE
The lot stays vacant, and the city's parks crew keeps mowing it.
The cost of a no, stated plainly. There is no pressure in it, and none is needed.
ALTERNATIVE
Grant the same permission for the north half of the lot only, with a review at the commission's November 2027 meeting.A smaller yes the commission can choose instead of no.
ATTACHED (2 pages): lumber quote; pledge list.
Ines Moreau and one other member will attend the November 24 meeting and can answer questions before it.
The page does not argue the case at length. The meeting is where questions are answered, and the spoken side is Learn Everyday Speaking's chapter Running a meeting.
Nine households pledged, but the page does not lean on the count. What a body can act on is the motion, the cost and who answers for the work, and whatever its own rules let it do. The rules are the commission's, and its clerk can say what they are.
A reference: a letter for a coworker
Theo Brandt was once on the asking end of a recommendation letter. A year later his coworker Mina Park asks him for one. He agrees only after checking that he can write it from what he saw, and she sends him the job posting and her resume first. The chapter behind this piece is Praise, references and reviews.
Fictional example
Theo Brandt, Mina Park, Harbor Hardware, Cedar Lane Home Supply and its hiring manager are fictional. Known (from the case): Theo and Mina work at Harbor Hardware; she is applying to Cedar Lane Home Supply, whose hiring manager is Ms. Alvarez; his store manager says he may write as an individual but not on store letterhead. Assumed for this example: the job, how long they have worked together, and the events he describes. Open: nothing the letter needs settled. Whether Mina gets the job is Cedar Lane's decision.
From: Theo Brandt [his personal email]
To: Ms. Alvarez, Cedar Lane Home Supply
Subject: Reference for Mina Park, assistant managerSent from his own address, not the store's, because he writes as an individual.
Dear Ms. Alvarez,
I am writing in support of Mina Park's application for the assistant manager position at Cedar Lane Home Supply. I have worked beside her on the same weekend shifts at Harbor Hardware for twelve months, as a coworker. I am not her supervisor, and I am writing as an individual.The relationship, how long, and in what capacity, in the first paragraph. UNC's Writing Center tells letter writers to "Say how long you've known the applicant and in what capacity." "I am not her supervisor" stops a reader from assuming more than Theo can speak to.
In March, when our shift lead was out for three weeks, Mina wrote the weekend opening checklist we still use and trained two new hires on it. Both were opening on their own by their second weekend.A date, an act and an effect. No adjective in it does work that a fact can do. "We still use" is something Theo can see; whether the store adopted it as policy is not, so he does not say so.
During the July inventory count, she noticed that 40 cases of paint had been received under the wrong product number and traced them to one mislabeled pallet before the count closed.A second dated event, of a different kind: care with stock, where the first was training people.
In twelve months of weekend shifts together, I did not see her miss one or arrive late.Kept to what he saw. "I did not see her miss a shift" is a sentence he can stand behind for twelve months; a sentence about her whole working life is not.
I did not see her scheduling or ordering work, which our store manager handles, so I cannot speak to it.Saying what you cannot speak to makes the rest easier to believe. UNC's guidance warns that unsupported superlatives "are likely to meet with skepticism" unless specific evidence comes with them.
I would gladly work for her. I am happy to answer questions at 555-0187 or at this address.A recommendation inside his own standing: he is a coworker, so he says what a coworker can. The offer to answer questions is what a careful reader checking a reference wants.
Theo Brandt
The conventions in the notes come from the UNC Writing Center's page on letters of recommendation, which is written for faculty recommending students. We apply it to an everyday reference; its points about the relationship, specific evidence and asking for the applicant's materials carry over. The same page says that if you could not give a positive or detailed recommendation, "it is okay to decline". Nothing about Mina's health, family or pay is in the letter, and nothing of anyone else's private business belongs in one.
Instructions: opening the plant
A new hire at Valley Hearth Bakery starts on the 5:00 a.m. opening shift. Marisol Chen writes the opening steps, has one person follow them without help, and fixes where that person stopped. This is the plant-opening sheet; the chapter works its companion page, oven 2 and the first rack. The chapter behind both is Writing instructions, and Instructions and test runs holds the step table and the tester log.
Fictional example
Valley Hearth Bakery, its layout, its equipment and everyone named here are fictional. Known (from the case): Marisol writes the opening-shift instructions for a new hire, and the opening shift runs 5:00 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. Assumed for this example: every time, switch, phone number, date and piece of equipment. Open: nothing that the sheet itself settles. The oven start-up is deliberately not on it: lighting the gas ovens is the maintenance lead's job under the oven's posted procedure, which is where this manual's line on hazardous work falls.
VALLEY HEARTH BAKERY: OPENING THE PLANT
Version 2, November 20, 2026. Written by Marisol Chen. Changed after a test run on November 19.A version and a date, so an old copy taped to a wall can be spotted and thrown out.
Who this is for: a new hire on the opening shift who has had the plant tour and food safety training, including mornings when you are the first one in.
What you need: your key fob and your alarm code (given to you in person; the code is not written on this sheet), a hair net and apron, and the opening log clipboard.
How long: about 35 minutes, from 5:00 a.m. to the first mix at 5:35 a.m.
Done looks like: alarm off, lights on, the walk-in reading logged, the first-mix butter and eggs at the scaling station, both ovens showing green, and the log signed.Everything the reader needs before the first step, above the first step. "Done looks like" tells them when to stop.
CAUTION, BEFORE YOU OPEN THE DOOR: If you are the first one in, the alarm sounds 30 seconds after the side door opens. Have your code ready before you touch the door.The warning goes before the step it warns about, because opening the door starts the clock. In version 1 this line came after the door step, and the tester read it with the alarm already counting.
1. Open the side door at the loading dock with your key fob.
2. Enter your code on the panel to the right of the door and press OFF. The panel reads READY when the alarm is off.
3. Switch on the production-floor lights: switches 1 to 4 on the panel beside the time clock.
4. Clock in.
5. Put on a hair net and apron from the bin beside the time clock.
6. Read the thermometer on the walk-in cooler door. Write the reading and the time on the opening log.One action per step, in the order they happen, each beginning with a verb. The same thing has the same name every time: it is "the walk-in" on every line, not "the cooler" on one line and "the fridge" on the next.
CAUTION, BEFORE YOU TAKE ANYTHING OUT: If the reading is above the red line printed on the log, do not take anything out of the walk-in. Call Marisol at (559) 555-0142 and wait for her answer.A stop point, before the step it stops. The red line is printed on the log, so the sheet does not need to carry a number of its own.
7. Take the butter and eggs listed on the first-mix sheet out of the walk-in and set them at the scaling station.
8. Check that both deck ovens show a green READY light. The maintenance lead lights and checks the ovens; you do not. If a light is not green by 5:30 a.m., call the maintenance lead at (559) 555-0151.The sheet says who owns the ovens and what to do if they are not ready. It does not say how to light one.
9. Sign the opening log.
10. Text Marisol "Open" and the time.
IF SOMETHING DOES NOT WORK
- The fob will not open the door: stay in your car with the doors locked and call Marisol.
- The alarm will not turn off: call the alarm company at the number on the sticker inside the panel door, then call Marisol.
- Anything else: call Marisol, then the maintenance lead.What to do when a step fails goes after the steps. Early in the morning the reader may be the only one in the building, and this section is who they call.
Tested November 19, 2026 by a packer from the afternoon line who had not opened before, coming in at 5:00 a.m. with Ruben Soto, who opens now, watching and not helping. She stopped twice: at the alarm panel (the code warning came after the door step) and at the light switches (the panel was not named). Both are fixed in this version. Second test run: the next new hire's first opening shift.The test is the evidence that the instructions can be followed. A second run is planned because Digital.gov's testing guide says to "Plan to test at least twice."
The testing advice in the last note is from Digital.gov's guide to testing for understanding, which also names usability testing and paraphrase testing as the formal methods. One person who has not done the task before, watched without help, is the smallest version of the same test. Preference
Adapting a shape to your piece
- Start from the ask, not the template. Write your one sentence first, in The piece plan, then pick the shape above that holds an ask like yours.
- Replace every fact with one of yours that has a date and a document. Where you have no document, cut the line rather than keep the example's. Evidence and numbers is where yours are listed.
- Keep the order, change the words. The order (reference, ask, facts oldest first, attachments, next step) is what transfers. The sentences are the cases' own; Sentences that do a job has patterns to fill instead.
- Check the office's own route before you send. If it has a form, a portal or an address for this kind of letter, use it. Where it goes next lists the published routes for common cases.
- Cut it and test it. Cutting it down covers the read-aloud and the one-reader test, and the draft check counts the words and flags the longest paragraph.