Praise, references and reviews
Complaints, praise and instructions

Praise, thank-yous, references and reviews

A commendation that names the act and the date, a reference letter you can stand behind, and a public review that is honest and useful to the next buyer.

Start here Essentials

A thank-you, a reference and a review are one piece at three sizes: a named person or business, a date, a thing that happened, and what it changed.

  1. Name the person or the business, the date, and the one thing that happened. One act, not a character sketch (praise someone can use).
  2. Say what effect it had, in one sentence. What it saved, fixed or made possible (the four parts).
  3. Send it to the person who writes their review, or post it where a buyer will see it. A manager for praise; the platform buyers read for a review (a review a stranger can use).
  4. Keep a copy if it is a reference. You may be asked about it, or asked again (a reference letter).

Minimum time: about 20 minutes. Done when: your piece names a date and an action, and contains no sentence you could not support.

Praise someone can use Understand

Praise is persuasive writing too. It asks a reader to believe something about a person or a business, and sometimes to act on it: to note it in a review, to hire someone, to book a company or to avoid one. What makes it believable is the same thing that makes a complaint actionable. It is specific, it is dated, and it is about something the writer saw.

Usable praise has four parts:

  1. The name. The person, spelled the way they spell it, and their role if the reader may not know it.
  2. The date. The day it happened, or the week. "So helpful" has no date, so nobody can check it or recall the day.
  3. The act. What they did, in a sentence with a verb: stayed late, called back, caught the error, explained the form.
  4. The effect. What it changed for you: the appointment you kept, the refund that came through, the fee you did not pay.
Written asWhat is missingWritten so someone can use it
"Thanks for everything."The act, the date, the effect"Thank you for staying after closing on November 3 to walk me through the returns screen. I ran it alone the next Saturday without calling anyone."
"Your staff are wonderful."Which staff, what they did"Ana at your front desk found my missing paperwork on October 28 and faxed it to my insurer the same afternoon. My claim was paid that week."
"Best plumber ever, five stars."Everything a buyer needs"Called on a Sunday about a leaking supply line. He came within two hours, replaced the line, and charged the price he quoted on the phone."

All three rewrites are fictional examples. Notice that the third is a review, not a thank-you: the reader is a stranger deciding whether to call, so the effect is written for them.

Who reads it, and why that changes where it goes

A commendation, in this manual, is praise sent to the person who supervises the one you are praising, so that it can count for something: a note in a file, a line in a review, a word at a staff meeting. Preference We send praise for a named person to their manager or the office that employs them, with a copy to the person. A thank-you sent only to the person is kind; the same words sent to their manager also become a record their manager can use. Ask the front desk or the switchboard who that manager is, the same way you would for a complaint.

A thank-you note is the same four parts with the effect turned toward the person. Preference Write one act and one effect, by hand or by email, within a week or two, and leave out the general adjectives. The specific act is what tells them it is not a form letter. A thank-you that could have been sent to anyone reads as if it was.

A reference letter you can stand behind

A reference letter (also called a letter of recommendation) is a letter about a person, written for someone who is deciding about them: an employer, a program, a landlord, a volunteer coordinator. It is praise with a reader who will weigh it against other letters.

The published guidance we found is from one source: the Writing Center at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, whose page on letters of recommendation is written for faculty recommending students. Convention It is one writing center's guidance for academic letters, and we apply it here to everyday references. Four of its points carry over directly:

  • Say how you know the person. The page says: "Say how long you've known the applicant and in what capacity." A coworker of a year, a former manager, a neighbor who hired them twice: each is a different kind of evidence, and the reader needs to know which they are reading.
  • Ask for their materials. The page suggests asking to see the applicant's resume, personal statement or other parts of the application. For an everyday reference, ask for the job posting or the program description too, so your examples answer what the reader is deciding.
  • Give specific evidence. The page warns that "sparse or non-specific recommendations may negatively impact an application."
  • Be careful with superlatives. It says unsupported superlatives "are likely to meet with skepticism, unless the writer includes specific evidence". "The best employee I have worked with" is a claim; the example that follows it is the evidence.

What you can speak to, and what you cannot

Preference Before you write, divide what you know into two lists: what you saw yourself, with dates, and what you only heard or assume. The letter is built from the first list. A sentence that says what you cannot speak to ("I did not see her budgeting work, which our manager handles") is not a weakness in a reference. It tells the reader how far to trust the rest, and it keeps you inside what you could defend if asked.

A coworker can usually speak toA coworker usually cannot speak to
How long and in what role you worked togetherPay, discipline records or formal performance reviews
Specific things you saw them do, with datesWork done on shifts or projects you were not on
How they handled a problem you were both part ofWhy they are leaving, beyond what they have told you to say
Whether you would work with them again, and in what roleAnything medical, family or personal

That table is this manual's working list, not a rule. A former manager can speak to more of the right-hand column, and whether they may is a question for their employer, below.

If you are writing in your work role

You may hear that employers only confirm dates and a job title. Some do, by their own policy. Others let managers write full references, and some say nothing about it. Practice varies from employer to employer, and we found no source that states a general rule. Ask the authority If you are writing as a manager, on the company's letterhead or from a work email, ask your manager or your human resources office first whether there is a policy, and write down the answer. If you are writing as an individual who happens to know the person from work, say so in the letter.

The shape of the letter

Purdue University's Online Writing Lab gives the parts of a formal business letter in this order: sender's address, date, inside address, salutation, body, closing, enclosures, typist initials. Convention A reference sent by email keeps the salutation, body and closing and usually drops the addresses and initials; the date is on the email itself. Preference Inside the body, we use four short paragraphs:

  1. Who you are, how long you have known the person and in what capacity, and what you are recommending them for.
  2. Two or three specific things you saw, each with a date or a season and an effect.
  3. What you cannot speak to, in one sentence, if anything the reader would expect is outside what you saw.
  4. Your recommendation in plain words, and how to reach you with questions.

Ask the person when it is due and where it goes, and send it a few days early. Keep a copy, with the date you sent it. You may be called about it, and the same person may ask you again next year.

Go deeper

Letters about students. If you are a teacher, coach or instructor, UNC's page notes that grades and other protected student information need the student's prior written consent under FERPA, the federal student privacy law. Ask the student for that consent in writing before you mention grades, and ask your school how it handles the form. Ask the authority

Letters you are asked to draft for your own signature. Some people will offer to write the letter for you to sign. If you accept, rewrite it until every sentence is something you saw. A letter that sounds like the applicant tends to read that way to the person deciding, and your signature says the words are yours.

A reference by phone. The same two lists apply. Write your three examples on a card before the call, and say what you cannot speak to rather than guessing.

Saying no to a reference

You can decline, and sometimes you should. UNC's Writing Center says that if you do not feel you could provide a positive or detailed recommendation, it is okay to decline, and it lists reasons: you do not have enough information about the person, the request is a poor fit with your field, you lack the credentials the reader expects, or there is not enough time before the deadline. Convention

Declining is often kinder than a flat letter. The same page warns that sparse or non-specific letters may hurt an application, so a lukewarm letter from you may do the person more harm than a strong letter from someone else. Declining early gives them time to ask that someone else.

Preference Decline in two or three sentences, soon after you are asked, with the real reason in plain words and without a long apology. Where you can, point them toward someone who saw more of their work:

Thank you for thinking of me. I only worked with you for two weeks, and I do not think I could write the detailed letter this deserves.The reason, in terms of what you saw, not a judgment of them. Your shift lead from the spring would be able to say much more.A better writer for the letter, named by role. Good luck with the application.

If the reason is that what you saw was not good, you do not have to say that. "I do not think I am the right person to write this" is true and enough.

A review a stranger can use

A public review is written for one reader: a stranger deciding whether to buy, book or hire. Everything in it should help that decision. Preference Ours has four parts:

  • When, and what you bought. The date, the service or product, and its size: "a local move, studio apartment, three movers, October".
  • What happened. What you saw, in order, including what went well. A review that only reports the bad part tells a buyer less than one that reports both.
  • What happened next. How the business answered a problem, if there was one, and whether that is still open. Say "still open" when it is.
  • What you would have wanted to know. One line addressed to the next buyer: the question to ask, the photo to take, the clause to read.
A review that is a moodA review a stranger can use
"Worst company ever. Avoid.""Moved on Sunday, October 18. Crew on time, finished in four hours at the quoted rate. A table leg broke on the stairs; claim filed October 20 and still open."
"They're scammers who don't care.""I was quoted $340 by phone and billed $415. The office said the difference was a stair fee that was not on the quote."
"Five stars, amazing.""Booked two days out for a broken dryer. Fixed on the first visit; the part was in the van."

Both columns are fictional. The left column is not more honest for being angrier. "Scammers" is a conclusion about what a business intends, which you rarely know; what you know is the quote, the bill and what the office told you. Write that, and the reader can draw the conclusion themselves.

Preference Three things to leave out of a public review. Leave out guesses about why people did what they did. Leave out anyone's private information, including a worker's full name, their appearance and anything you learned about their life. And leave out threats, including a threat to keep posting. Praise for a named worker goes to their manager as a commendation, not into a public post. If the business fixes the problem later, update the review and say what changed and when.

Limits

The standard this chapter teaches is honest and accurate: what you saw, when, and what you can speak to. Whether a particular sentence is defamatory is a legal question under your state's law, and a lawyer answers it. The federal rules quoted in the next section are about fake and suppressed reviews. They are not about how carefully you must phrase a true one.

What the federal rules say about reviews Go deeper

Two federal sources govern reviews in ways a reviewer may meet. Neither tells you how to write one, and neither decides whether a sentence you wrote is true.

Your contract and your review: 15 U.S.C. 45b

The Consumer Review Fairness Act of 2016, at 15 U.S.C. 45b, deals with clauses in a form contract, the statute's term for a standard contract offered to consumers; the statute's own definition is on the linked page. Under 45b(b)(1), a form-contract provision "is void from the inception of such contract" if it prohibits or restricts the ability of an individual who is a party to the contract to engage in a covered communication, if it imposes a penalty or fee for doing so, or if it transfers or requires the transfer of intellectual property rights in the review (a non-exclusive license is the exception). Section 45b(c) makes it unlawful to offer a form contract containing such a provision.

A covered communication, under 45b(a)(2), is a written, oral or pictorial review, performance assessment or similar analysis of goods, services or conduct, by an individual who is a party to the form contract; the statute counts photographs, video, illustrations and symbols. The same section also keeps some things in place, under 45b(b)(2) and (b)(3): duties of confidentiality, claims for defamation, and a host's right to remove content, including content that is clearly false or misleading. So the Act is about clauses that restrict an honest review; it does not protect a false one, and whether a sentence is false or defamatory is the question the Limits box sends to a lawyer.

Ask the authority Whether a clause in your own contract is covered, and whether your contract is a form contract under the statute, are questions for a lawyer or your state's consumer protection office.

The FTC's rule on reviews: 16 CFR Part 465

The Federal Trade Commission's Rule on the Use of Consumer Reviews and Testimonials, 16 CFR Part 465, was adopted at 89 FR 68077, August 22, 2024. Three of its sections matter to someone writing a review.

  • What counts as a review. Under 16 CFR 465.1(d), a consumer review is "a consumer's evaluation, or a purported consumer's evaluation, of a product, service, or business" published to a website or platform that receives and displays such evaluations, and "consumer reviews include consumer ratings regardless of whether they include any text or narrative." A star rating with no words is a review under the rule.
  • Fake and bought reviews. Under 16 CFR 465.2, it is a violation for a business to write, create or sell a consumer review that materially misrepresents that the reviewer exists, had the experience, or what the experience was; to buy such a review or spread such a testimonial when it knew or should have known; or to procure reviews from its own officers, managers, employees or agents, or their immediate relatives, for a third-party platform, on the same knowledge standard. Section 465.2(d) excepts reviews that come from "generalized solicitations to purchasers to post reviews" and from a business merely hosting reviews. The rule's text sets out the conditions in full; if your own employer asks you to review it, 465.2(c) is the section about that request.
  • Review suppression. Under 16 CFR 465.7(a), it is an unfair or deceptive practice for anyone to use "an unfounded or groundless legal threat, a physical threat, intimidation, or a public false accusation" in response to a review, made knowing it was false or with "reckless disregard as to its truth or falsity", to stop a review being written or to get one removed. Under 465.7(b), a business may not misrepresent that the reviews it displays represent most or all of those submitted when it has suppressed some because of their ratings or negative sentiment. The exception is for criteria "applied equally to all reviews submitted without regard to sentiment", and the rule's examples include defamatory, harassing or abusive content, personal information, content that is clearly false or misleading, a review the seller reasonably believes is fake, and content wholly unrelated to the products or services.

Two practical readings for a reviewer. First, review suppression (a business keeping reviews from being written or seen because they are negative) is the rule's subject, and 465.7(a) is the section to read if a business threatens you over a review. Keep the threat, with its date, and do not answer it in public. Second, the 465.7(b) exceptions are a reminder that a business or platform may leave out content of those kinds, under criteria applied to every review alike. A review that reports what you saw, with dates, and leaves out other people's private information gives them nothing of that kind to weigh.

The rule is new, and the link re-check for this manual reads it again each year. Ask the authority What the FTC does about a particular business is the FTC's decision, and whether your review is defamatory is a lawyer's question under state law.

See it: a reference for a coworker, and a review of a move See it

Fictional example

Theo Brandt writes two pieces. In the fall of 2026, Two Rivers Moving broke his dining table on a move, and he reviews the company. About a year after asking his own former instructor for a recommendation, he is asked for one himself: a coworker, Mina Park, wants a reference for an assistant manager job at another store. Every name here is fictional: Theo, Mina, Harbor Hardware where they work, Cedar Lane Home Supply where she is applying, its hiring manager, Two Rivers Moving and its crew lead.

Known. Theo and Mina have worked the same weekend shifts at Harbor Hardware for twelve months. He is a coworker, not her supervisor. She sent him her resume and the job posting. Two Rivers moved Theo on Sunday, October 18, 2026; a table leg broke on the stairs, and the crew lead photographed it and noted it on the paperwork before Theo signed. Theo filed a damage claim with Two Rivers on Tuesday, October 20, and as of November 10 has an acknowledgment, no decision.

Assumed. That a coworker's letter is useful to the hiring manager alongside a supervisor's. That is Mina's assumption; the posting asks for two references and does not say whose. That Harbor Hardware has no policy on employees giving references. That is Theo's assumption, and he does not leave it there.

Open. Whether Harbor Hardware lets employees write references about coworkers. Settled by: the store manager, whom Theo asks before writing; the answer is that he may, as an individual, but not on store letterhead. Whether Two Rivers will repair or pay for the table. Settled by: Two Rivers, through its claim process, and after that by the routes on Learn Conflict Management's Where to take it next.

His reference, sent by email from his personal address:

Subject: Reference for Mina Park, assistant manager Dear Ms. Alvarez, I am writing to recommend Mina Park for the assistant manager position at Cedar Lane Home Supply. I have worked alongside Mina on the same weekend shifts at Harbor Hardware for twelve months, as a coworker. I am not her supervisor, and I am writing as an individual.How long and in what capacity, as UNC's page asks, and what kind of view this is. "As an individual" follows his store manager's answer. In March, when our shift lead was out for three weeks, Mina wrote the weekend opening checklist we still use, and trained two new hires on it. Both were opening on their own by their second weekend.The act, its date and its effect. The posting asks for training experience, so this example comes first. During the July inventory count, she noticed that 40 cases of paint had been received under the wrong product number and traced it to one mislabeled pallet before the count closed.A second specific, from a different part of the job. I did not see her scheduling or ordering work, which our store manager handles, so I cannot speak to it.What he cannot speak to, in one sentence. It tells the reader how far to trust the rest. I recommend her for this role, and I would gladly work for her. I am happy to answer questions at 555-0187 or at this address. Theo Brandt

There is no "best employee I have ever met" in it. Theo has worked at one store for one year, and the hiring manager will weigh the letter knowing that. He keeps a copy in a folder with the date he sent it.

His review, posted on the platform where he found Two Rivers, about three weeks after the move:

Local move, studio apartment, three movers, October 18.When, and what he bought, so a buyer can compare it with their own move. The crew arrived at 8:00 as scheduled, finished in about four hours, and billed the hourly rate I was quoted.What went well, stated as plainly as what went wrong. Carrying my dining table down the stairs, a leg snapped at the joint. The crew lead stopped, photographed it and wrote it on the paperwork before I signed. I filed a damage claim on October 20. As of November 10 I have an acknowledgment and no decision.What happened next, with dates, and "no decision" rather than a guess about what the decision will be. If you book them: ask how damage claims are handled and how long they take, and photograph your furniture before the move.One line for the next buyer. I will update this when the claim is decided.

What is not in it: "careless", "they don't care", the crew lead's name, and any guess about how the claim will go. The crew lead's quick note on the paperwork deserves praise of its own, and Theo sends that separately to the Two Rivers office as a commendation: the date, what the crew lead did, and that it made the claim simple to file. The claim itself is a complaint, and Complaining so it gets fixed covers how to write it; what the company owes for the table is not a writing question. Damage, delays and disputes in Plan Your House Move covers a mover's claim deadlines and where to complain.

Practice: one piece of praise, checked line by line Practice

Minimum: one commendation, thank-you or review, with a date and an act in it and every sentence checked against what you saw. Time: about 20 minutes; a reference letter takes about an hour, including the questions you ask first. Materials: your dates (a receipt, a calendar, an email), the name and role of the person, and, for a reference, the person's resume and the posting. Six letters, annotated has a reference letter marked up part by part, and the praise sheet in Before it goes out holds this chapter's checks.

  1. Pick one act. Not a summary of a person or a year: one thing they did on one day.
  2. Write the four parts as four short lines. Name, date, act, effect. Check the name's spelling against something they wrote.
  3. Turn the lines into two or three sentences for the reader you chose. The person, their manager, or a stranger deciding whether to buy.
  4. Mark every sentence S (saw) or H (heard or assumed). Cut or rewrite every H, or say plainly that it is what you were told.
  5. Send it to the right reader. Praise for a named person to their manager with a copy to them; a review where buyers read; a reference to the address the person gave you, with a copy kept.
Go deeper

A full reference letter. Ask the person for their resume, the posting and the deadline. Ask your employer about any policy if you are writing in your work role. Write the two lists (saw, did not see), choose two or three examples that match what the posting asks for, and draft the four paragraphs. Read it aloud once, then send it a few days early.

A review, revisited. Find a review you posted in the past. Rewrite it with the four parts, and check it against the Limits box: is every sentence something you saw, with a date?

A decline, drafted. Write the two or three sentences you would send if someone asked you for a reference you could not write well. Having the words ready makes it easier to answer quickly, which is the kind part.

What you are writing What you are writing

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does the piece name a person or business, a date and one act?
  • Does it say what effect the act had?
  • Is every sentence something you saw, or plainly marked as what you were told?
  • For praise of a named person: is it going to the person who writes their review, with a copy to them?
  • For a reference: does it say how long you have known the person and in what capacity, give specific examples, and say what you cannot speak to?
  • For a review: does it say when, what you bought, what happened, what happened next, and one thing the next buyer should know?
  • Is there anything in it that is someone else's private information, a guess about motives, or a threat?

Worked example

Theo's reference to Ms. Alvarez passes. It opens with twelve months, same shifts, coworker, not supervisor. Its two examples have a month each and an effect each, and the first matches what the posting asks for. It names the work he did not see. It has no superlative he could not back up, and he asked his store manager before writing. His review passes too: the date and the size of the move are in the first line, the good part is reported, the broken table is described as he saw it, and the claim is "no decision" rather than a prediction. The crew lead's name went to the office in a commendation, not into the public post.

Common mistakes

  • Adjectives instead of acts. "Dedicated, hardworking, a team player" tells the reader nothing they can weigh. Replace each adjective with the act that made you think it.
  • Praise sent only to the person. It is kind, and their manager rarely hears about it. Send it to the manager with a copy.
  • A flat reference instead of a decline. A short, general letter can hurt more than no letter. If you cannot write a specific one, say so early.
  • Writing beyond what you saw. A coworker guessing at someone's performance review, or a reviewer guessing at a company's motives.
  • A review written on the worst day. Wait until you can report what happened next, or say that it is still open.
  • Naming a worker in a public complaint. Their manager is the place for that, praise or complaint.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not tell you whether a sentence in your review is defamatory; that is a question of your state's law for a lawyer. It does not tell you whether a clause in a contract you signed is void under 15 U.S.C. 45b, which is also a lawyer's question, or a state consumer protection office's. Whether your employer lets you write a reference in your work role is the employer's answer. Asking someone else for a reference, and what to send them, is in Asking for something. If the review is about a problem the business has not fixed yet, the complaint comes first, and Complaining so it gets fixed is where that starts.

Knowledge check and scenario

A thank-you says "You were so helpful, thank you for everything." What would make it usable?
A date, one act and its effect: "Thank you for staying after closing on November 3 to show me the returns screen; I ran it alone the next Saturday." Sent to the person's manager with a copy to them, the same lines also become something the manager can use. Without the act and the date, nobody can check the note or tie it to a day.
A neighbor you have met twice asks you for a character reference for an apartment. What does the guidance we cite say, and what would you do?
UNC's Writing Center, writing about academic letters, says it is okay to decline when you could not write a positive or detailed recommendation, and lists not knowing enough about the person among the reasons. It also warns that sparse, non-specific letters may hurt an application. So decline early, in two or three sentences, and if you can, suggest someone who knows them better. If you do write, say exactly how long and in what capacity you know them, and keep to what you saw.
Your manager asks you to write a reference for a former employee. Is there a rule on what you may say?
Not one we found. Some employers limit references by their own policy, sometimes to dates and job title; others do not. Practice varies, and no source we read states a general rule. Ask your manager or human resources whether your employer has a policy before you write in your work role, and write down the answer.
(Go deeper) A service contract says you will be charged a fee if you post a negative review. What does 15 U.S.C. 45b say about that?
Under 45b(b)(1), a provision in a form contract that imposes a penalty or fee for a covered communication is "void from the inception of such contract", as is one that prohibits or restricts the review itself, and 45b(c) makes offering such a contract unlawful. The same statute preserves defamation claims and a host's right to remove clearly false content, so it protects an honest review, not a false one. Whether your contract is a form contract, and anything about your specific case, is for a lawyer or your state's consumer protection office.
You posted a two-star review of a contractor, with dates: the job finished three weeks late and the final bill was $600 over the written estimate. The contractor's office emails you: remove the review in 48 hours or they will sue.
"Liars" is a conclusion about intent, which you do not know, and it is the kind of sentence that turns a dispute about dates and dollars into a dispute about you. The update also puts private correspondence in public before anyone has advised you on it. Keep the review to what you saw.
This keeps the decision on the facts. If every sentence is something you saw, with its date and the estimate to back it, you know what you wrote and can show it. The email goes in your records with its date; for reference, 16 CFR 465.7(a) is the federal rule on threats made to get a review removed. Whether any sentence is defamatory, and what to do about the threat, are questions for a lawyer under your state's law.
Reasonable if you are worried and cannot get advice before the deadline, and you can repost it later. The tradeoff is that the next buyer loses the information meanwhile, and taking it down does not answer whether it was accurate. Save a copy of the review, with its date, before you remove it.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.