Proposing something to a group
Asking for something

Writing a one-page proposal for a group that has to decide

One page with the decision you want written as a motion, the cost, who does the work, what happens if nothing is done, and the date the group meets.

Start here Essentials

A group decides by its own procedure, on a date it sets. Your page has to reach the person who builds the agenda in time, and it has to say what the group would be agreeing to.

  1. Write the decision you want as a motion. One sentence, beginning with a verb, that the group could adopt as written (the motion).
  2. Find the agenda deadline and who holds it, and ask for it in writing. That date is your real deadline, not the meeting (the agenda deadline).
  3. Put the cost, who does the work, and what happens if nothing is done on the same page. Each number says where it came from (the one page).
  4. Send it before the deadline and offer to answer questions. Name one contact and how to reach them (at the meeting).

Minimum time: about two hours, plus the wait for the clerk's reply. Done when: your page states the motion, the cost, the owner and the date, and fits on one side.

Who decides, and by what procedure Understand

A proposal, in this manual, is a piece of writing that asks a group to adopt a specific decision: a condo board to repaint the parking lines, a club to change its dues, a city commission to let neighbors garden on a vacant lot. What makes it different from a request to one person is that nobody reading it can say yes alone. The group decides together, under rules, at a meeting, and your page has to work inside that procedure.

Before you write, find out three things: who decides, by what procedure, and what the group is allowed to do. All three are usually published, and when they are not, they are askable.

Kind of groupWho usually decidesWhere the procedure is usually writtenWho to ask
A condo or homeowners' association boardA vote of the boardThe bylaws and the association's governing documentsThe board secretary or the management company
A club, a parent group or a volunteer committeeA vote of the members or the committeeIts bylaws, if it has themThe secretary or the chair
A workplace committeeOften a manager, after the committee recommendsA charter, a policy, or nowhereThe chair
A city board or commissionA vote at a public meetingThe ordinance or charter that created it, and its rules of procedureThe clerk or the staff member assigned to it
A federal agency's proposed ruleThe agency, after a comment periodThe notice that announces the proposalThe contact named in the notice

Preference That table is this manual's summary of common arrangements, not a rule for any one group. The group's own documents are the authority, and two groups of the same kind can work very differently.

The third question, what the group is allowed to do, is the one people skip. A homeowners' board may control the common areas and have no say over a city street. A commission may be able to recommend a sale of land and not approve one. A proposal that asks for something outside the group's power gets referred elsewhere or set aside, however good it is. The group's rules say what it can do; the clerk or the chair can point you to the clause.

The agenda deadline is the real deadline

An agenda is the list of items a group will take up at a meeting, published before it. Most groups that meet on a schedule close the agenda some days ahead, so that members can read the materials. The date by which an item and its papers have to reach the person who builds the agenda is the agenda deadline, and it is the date that matters. A page that arrives the day before the meeting is usually too late for that meeting, however early it is for the meeting itself.

Ask the authority The person who holds the agenda is usually a clerk, a secretary or the chair. Ask them in writing: when is the agenda deadline for the next meeting, how do I get an item on it, and in what form should the materials come? A written answer gives you a date you can rely on and a name to send to.

Limits

A proposal that is not on the agenda is not a decision, and a public comment is not a vote. Neither the number of signatures nor the strength of feeling is what the group is required to weigh. What it can act on is reasoning, evidence, and whatever its own rules let it do. This chapter is how to write the page; it does not say whether the group has the power to grant what you ask, or whether a decision it makes is lawful. Its own rules, its clerk or counsel, and a lawyer answer those.

The decision, written as a motion

A motion is a proposal put to a group for decision, worded so the group can adopt it exactly as written. Writing yours as a motion does two things. It forces you to say precisely what you want, and it saves the group from having to turn your page into something it can vote on, which is work somebody may not do.

A motion is one sentence. It begins with a verb the group can perform (approve, grant, adopt, authorize, refer), and it names who, what, where, when, and on what conditions.

Not a motionWhy the group cannot adopt itA motion
We hope the commission will support community gardening.No action, no place, no dateGrant the Pine Street garden group permission to use the city lot at 118 Pine Street as a community garden from April 1 to October 31, 2027.
The parking lot needs attention.A description, not a decisionAuthorize the manager to have the parking lines repainted before May 31, at a cost of no more than the attached quote.
Dues should be fairer."Fairer" is a feeling, not a figureReduce annual dues for members over 65 from $40 to $20, starting with the January renewal.
Look into a crosswalk on Elm Street.Nobody is named to do the lookingRefer the request for a crosswalk at Elm and Third to the traffic committee, with a report due at the March meeting.

The last row shows that a motion does not have to ask for the final decision. Asking a group to refer something, to study it, or to put it on a later agenda is a legitimate motion, and sometimes it is the only one the group can adopt this month.

Preference Writing the ask as a motion is this manual's rule for a proposal; a group's own rules may use other words for it (a resolution, an item, a recommendation). Put the motion at the top of the page, before anything else. The plain-language rule Digital.gov states, "Put the most important information at the beginning", is the reason, and in a proposal the motion is the most important information. How the group then records what it decided is Learn Everyday Speaking's Decisions and minutes.

One page: the cost, the owner, the alternative

Under the motion, the page answers the questions a member asks before voting. Lay it out in this order, each part under a short heading or as one labeled line.

PartWhat it saysLength
The motionThe decision, as the group would adopt itOne sentence
WhyThe fact that makes this worth deciding nowTwo or three sentences
CostEvery number, who pays it, and where each figure came fromA short list
Who does the workThe owner: a named person or group, and what they will do by whenTwo or three lines
If nothing is doneWhat happens if the group says no or does not decideOne or two sentences
The alternativeA smaller decision the group could adopt insteadOne sentence
Contact and dateOne person, how to reach them, and the meeting the page is forOne line
AttachedThe quotes, the map, the list of supporters, each namedOne line

Preference That order is this manual's. One page is a working limit, not a measured one: no source we found tests what length a board reads. It is a useful limit because it keeps you cutting. When the facts will not fit, the extra goes into an attachment of two pages or fewer, and the one page says what is in it. What the research supports lists "keep it to one page" with the other claims that get repeated without a source.

Every number says where it came from

A number in a proposal is the first thing a skeptical member checks. Each one carries its source on the same line: "lumber and soil, $1,140 (written quote, October 28)". A member who can see where a figure came from can argue with the source instead of with you.

Preference This manual's standing rule: a figure you cannot source comes out. An estimate you made yourself can stay if it says so ("our estimate, from last year's receipts"). A figure that is a guess dressed as a fact undoes the rest of the page when somebody finds it. The evidence you need, and where to find it covers gathering the quotes and records, and Evidence and numbers holds them.

The owner, and what happens if nothing is done

The owner of a proposal is the person or group who will do the work if it passes. Groups hesitate to approve something nobody is named to carry out, because the work then falls to the group. Name the owner, what they will do, and by when.

"If nothing is done" is the line people leave out because it feels negative. It is the line that tells the group what a no costs. Keep it factual: "The lot stays vacant and the parks crew continues to mow it monthly." Not "the neighborhood will decline."

The alternative

Offer one smaller decision the group could adopt if it will not adopt the motion: half the space, one season, a trial with a review date, a referral to a committee. A group that has doubts about the full proposal can then say yes to part of it at this meeting rather than no to all of it. It is the group version of offering two options in a request, which Asking a person or a business for something covers.

At the meeting

Send the page by the agenda deadline, to the person who holds the agenda, and ask them to confirm it is on the agenda. Name one contact. Offer to answer questions before the meeting, and say whether someone from your group will attend. If the group allows people to speak, plan to say the motion and the cost in under a minute and then answer questions; the page does the rest. Running the meeting itself, and how the group takes and records its decision, are Learn Everyday Speaking's Running a meeting and Decisions and minutes.

Commenting on a draft rule Go deeper

A public comment is a written response to a rule an agency or a body has proposed, submitted during a set period before the rule is final. It is a proposal of a kind: you are asking the body to change, keep or drop something specific in the draft. The difference is that you are one of many, and the decision is the body's alone.

The clearest published advice on writing one that we found is the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's page on commenting on its dockets. It is one agency's guidance for its own federal rules, not a rule for every body, but the advice travels. A docket is the file an agency keeps for one rulemaking, and its docket ID is the number that names it.

  • It is not a vote. EPA's page says "The comment process is not a vote", and that one well-supported comment often tells the agency more than a thousand form letters. EPA also says mass-mail campaigns are posted as one representative sample with a count.
  • Give grounds. Base the comment on "sound reasoning, scientific evidence, and/or how you will be impacted" by the proposal.
  • Be specific about the change. Say why you agree or disagree, and "suggest alternatives and substitute language for your requested changes."
  • Take on the other side. "Address trade-offs and opposing views." Describe your assumptions and the data you used.
  • Label it. Put the docket ID and the Federal Register date and page in the subject line, cite the section of the rule you are commenting on, and submit by the deadline in the notice.
  • Expect it to be public. EPA posts comments publicly, personal information included.

For a city or county rule, the same parts apply with local labels: the rule's number or file name and the date of the notice in the subject line, and the comment deadline from the notice itself. Preference That adaptation is ours. Ask the authority Whether a local body publishes comments, with names and addresses, and how it counts the deadline, is the clerk's answer; ask before you include anything you would not want posted. The notice you received governs the deadline for your comment, not any date in this manual.

The Pine Street garden group's comment on a draft parks rule, in the same fictional city as the example below:

Subject: Comment on Draft Parks Rule 2026-07 (notice dated November 2, 2026), section 4(c)The rule's number, the notice date and the section, so the comment reaches the right file and the right sentence. To the Portland land commission (a fictional body): We are the Pine Street garden group, nine households who have asked the commission for permission to garden on the city lot at 118 Pine Street. We support the purpose of section 4(c), keeping city land clear for winter maintenance, and ask that it be changed as follows.Says where they agree before what they want changed. Draft: "All raised beds shall be removed from city land by November 30 each year." Proposed: "All raised beds shall be removed from city land by November 30 each year, except beds no more than 12 inches high, set at least 10 feet from any sidewalk and marked with stakes at each corner."Substitute language, which EPA's page asks for, so the commission can adopt the change as written. How we would be affected: removing and rebuilding nine beds each year would cost us about $1,140 in lumber and soil (written quote, October 28) and two work days each spring.The impact, with a number and its source. The trade-off: low beds left in place take up some space that could hold plowed snow. The 10-foot setback is meant to keep the sidewalk edge clear for that. Parks crews may know of a better distance, and we would accept theirs.Takes on the opposing view instead of ignoring it. Our assumption: that the plows working the lot stay within 10 feet of the sidewalk. If that is wrong, the setback should change. Ines Moreau, for the Pine Street garden group inesmoreau@example.com
  • Commenting on EPA Dockets: the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency's advice on writing a comment, last updated October 1, 2026. One agency's guidance for its own rules.

Proposals, petitions, complaints and letters to officials Go deeper

Three kinds of writing go to a group, and they are easy to confuse. They ask for different things and are weighed differently.

KindWhat it asks forWhat it carriesWhere it usually goes
A proposalA specific decision, written as a motionReasoning, cost, an owner, an alternativeThe agenda, through the person who holds it
A petition: a statement signed by many people asking a body to actUsually a direction ("stop the closure", "add a crosswalk") rather than a worded decisionNumbers: how many people want itThe body, often presented at a meeting; some bodies have a formal petition process with its own rules
A complaint to a bodyA fix for something the body or its staff didDates, facts and the fix wantedThe body's complaint route, often staff rather than the agenda

Preference The distinctions are this manual's. A petition can be useful, and it shows a body that many people care. What it does not carry is the reasoning a body needs to act, which is EPA's point about form letters. If you have both, send the proposal as the item and the petition as an attachment that shows support. Ask the authority Whether a petition obliges a particular body to do anything depends on that body's own rules or the law that set it up; the clerk can say. A complaint about how a body or its staff treated you has its own shape, in Writing a complaint so that it gets fixed.

Writing to an elected official. When the decision belongs to a legislature, a council or an executive rather than a board you can address directly, the letter goes to the official who represents you. USAGov's page on finding and contacting elected officials (last updated March 2, 2026) gives the routes to the president, senators, representatives, governors, state legislators, mayors, county executives and city officials. Preference Three rules of this manual's own: one subject per letter, so it reaches the staff member who handles that subject; your street address, so the office can see you live in the district; and the specific bill, rule or decision by its number or name, with the action you want the official to take.

See it: a garden on a vacant lot See it

Fictional example

The Pine Street garden group is nine households in Portland, Maine, who want the city to let them use a vacant lot as a garden. They need one page for the land commission's November meeting. The Portland land commission in this example is a fictional body, and nobody here is a real person or office.

Known. The lot at 118 Pine Street is city-owned and has been vacant since 2019 (the city assessor's online record). The commission meets Tuesday, November 24, 2026, at 6:00 p.m. The clerk's email of November 3 says the agenda deadline is noon on Tuesday, November 10, and materials go to the clerk by email as one PDF. The parks office's email of October 20 says a crew mows the lot monthly from May to October. The group has a written quote for lumber and soil, dated October 28, for $1,140, and written pledges from all nine households totaling $1,400.

Assumed. That the commission has the power to grant a season's use of city land. The group's assumption. Settled by: the clerk, whom they asked in the same email; the answer is in the commission's rules of procedure.

Open. Whether the lot has a water connection, and what it costs to use. Settled by: the city water department. What insurance the city requires of a group on its land. Settled by: the city's risk management office. What form the permission takes (a permit, a license, a lease) and what its terms mean. Settled by: city staff, and for the meaning of any agreement the group signs, a lawyer.

Their first draft was three pages: the history of the neighborhood, a list of what each household wanted to grow, a paragraph on the benefits of gardens in general, and, on page three, "we hope the commission will consider our request." It had no motion, no cost, and no date. Here is the page they sent on Friday, November 6:

Pine Street garden group: proposal for the Portland land commission Meeting of Tuesday, November 24, 2026The meeting the page is for, at the top, so the clerk files it correctly. MOTION Grant the Pine Street garden group permission to use the city-owned lot at 118 Pine Street as a community garden from April 1 to October 31, 2027, on terms set by city staff, with the group paying all costs listed below.One sentence, a verb the commission can perform, the place, the dates and the condition. The commission could adopt it as written. WHY The lot has been vacant since 2019 (city assessor's record). Nine households within two blocks have pledged money and work to garden it for one season. COST Lumber and soil for nine raised beds: $1,140 (written quote, October 28, attached) Hand tools and hoses: $260 (our estimate, from store prices listed October 30) Paid by: the nine households, $1,400 pledged in writing (list attached) Cost to the city: none that we know of. Water connection and insurance: open; we have asked the water department and the risk management office.Every number with its source. The estimate is labeled as theirs. The two unknowns are named as open, with who is answering them. WHO DOES THE WORK The group builds the beds on April 3 and 10, mows the paths, and removes everything by October 31. Contact: Ines Moreau.The owner, the work and the dates. IF NOTHING IS DONE The lot stays vacant, and the parks crew continues to mow it monthly from May to October (parks office email, October 20).What a no costs, stated as a fact with its source. ALTERNATIVE Grant the same permission for the north half of the lot only, with a review at the commission's November 2027 meeting.A smaller decision the commission could adopt if it doubts the full one. Contact: Ines Moreau, inesmoreau@example.com, (207) 555-0163. Two of us will attend the meeting and can answer questions before it. Attached: lumber quote (1 page); pledge list (1 page).

The history of the neighborhood and the benefits of gardens in general are gone, not because they are untrue but because they are not what a commissioner needs in order to vote. What the space bought is the motion, the cost with its sources, an owner, and an alternative. The two open questions are on the page rather than hidden, because a commissioner who finds an unanswered question tends to vote to wait; one who sees it is already being answered can vote to approve on terms set by staff.

  • Organize the information: Digital.gov's plain-language guide, the source for putting the most important information first.
  • Running a meeting: Learn Everyday Speaking's chapter on purpose, agenda, roles and time, for the meeting where the page is heard.
  • Decisions and minutes: the same manual on how a group takes a decision and records it.

Practice: the motion and the page Practice

Minimum: a motion, a written question to the person who holds the agenda, and a one-page draft with the cost, the owner and the date. Time: about two hours, spread across the wait for the clerk's reply. Materials: the group's rules or website, any quotes or records behind your numbers, The piece plan and Six letters, annotated for the proposal's shape.

  1. Write the motion. One sentence, a verb the group can perform, and who, what, where, when and on what conditions. Read it aloud as if you were the chair putting it to a vote. If it needs explaining, rewrite it.
  2. Check the group can do it. Find the clause in the group's rules that gives it the power, or write down that you are asking the clerk.
  3. Email the person who holds the agenda. Ask for the agenda deadline, how to get an item on it, and the form the materials should take. Put their answer in The piece plan as your due date.
  4. List every number with its source. Any number without one either gets a source, gets labeled as your estimate, or comes out.
  5. Fill in the page in order: motion, why, cost, who does the work, if nothing is done, alternative, contact, attachments.
  6. Print it. If it runs onto a second side, move the detail into an attachment and say on the page what the attachment contains.
  7. Send it before the deadline, and ask for confirmation that it is on the agenda. Log the date in your Sent log and next rungs.
Go deeper

The member's read. Give the page to one person who knows nothing about it and ask: if you had to vote on this tonight, what would you be agreeing to, what would it cost, and who would do it? If any of the three answers is wrong, that part of the page needs work. Cutting it down and testing it before it goes covers the read-back.

The comment version. If a draft rule affects your proposal, write a comment in the shape in Commenting on a draft rule: the section, your substitute language, how you would be affected, and the trade-off. Check the notice for the comment deadline and write it on your plan.

What you are writing What you are writing

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Is the decision written as a motion the group could adopt word for word, at the top of the page?
  • Is it something the group has the power to do, and do you know where that power is written?
  • Do you know the agenda deadline and who holds it, from a written answer?
  • Is every number on the page followed by its source, or labeled as your estimate?
  • Does the page name the owner, what they will do, and by when?
  • Does it say what happens if nothing is done, and offer a smaller alternative?
  • Does it fit on one side, with anything longer as a named attachment?

Worked example

The Pine Street page passes each line. The motion is the first thing under the heading, and the commission could adopt it as written. The group asked the clerk both for the agenda deadline and for confirmation of the commission's power, in writing, and sent the page four days before the deadline. Each number has a source, and the $260 for tools is labeled as their own estimate. The owner is the group, with build dates and a contact. The alternative, half the lot with a review in a year, gives the commission something to approve if it has doubts. The page fits on one side with two one-page attachments. What it does not show is whether the commission will vote yes, which nothing on the page can settle.

Common mistakes

  • Writing to the meeting date instead of the agenda deadline. Notice it by asking yourself what the agenda deadline is; if you do not know, ask today.
  • A page with no motion. If the page ends with "we hope the board will consider", the group has nothing to vote on.
  • Asking for something outside the group's power. A good proposal to the wrong body is referred, at best.
  • A number with no source. The first member who checks it stops trusting the rest.
  • No owner. A group hesitates to approve work it will have to do itself.
  • Leaving out what a no costs. Without it, saying no looks free.
  • Relying on signatures. A petition shows support; it does not supply the reasoning a body acts on.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not settle whether the group will adopt your motion, whether it has the power to, or whether a decision it makes is lawful; its own rules, its clerk or counsel, and a lawyer answer those. It does not cover speaking at the meeting, which is Learn Everyday Speaking's Running a meeting, or recording the decision, which is its Decisions and minutes. Gathering the quotes and records behind your numbers is The evidence you need, and where to find it, and getting the page down to one side is Cutting it down and testing it before it goes. If what you need is one person's decision rather than a group's, Asking a person or a business for something is the shorter route.

Knowledge check and scenario

Why is the agenda deadline, not the meeting date, your real deadline?
Because a group that meets on a schedule usually closes its agenda some days ahead so members can read the materials. A page that misses the agenda deadline is usually too late for that meeting, even if it arrives well before the meeting itself. Ask the person who holds the agenda for the date, in writing.
What turns "we would like the board to look into the parking lot" into a motion?
A verb the board can perform, and the who, what, where, when and conditions: "Authorize the manager to have the parking lines repainted before May 31, at a cost of no more than the attached quote." The board can adopt that as written. "Look into" names no action and nobody to do it; if a study is what you want, the motion refers it to a named person or committee with a report date.
Why does the page say what happens if nothing is done?
Because it tells the group what a no costs. Without it, declining looks free. State it as a fact with a source ("the parks crew continues to mow it monthly"), not as a prediction about the neighborhood.
(Go deeper) Your neighborhood has collected 300 identical comments on a draft rule. What does EPA's guidance suggest you add?
One well-supported comment. EPA's page says "The comment process is not a vote", that one well-supported comment is often more informative than a thousand form letters, and that mass-mail campaigns are posted as a representative sample with a count. The comment it describes gives reasoning, evidence or how you would be affected, substitute language, and the trade-offs. That is EPA's guidance for its own rules; a local body's practice is the clerk's to explain.
Your condo board meets in ten days. The parking lines have worn off and cars are parking across two spaces. You have one contractor's written quote. What do you send?
Forty signatures show the board that owners care, and they arrive after the agenda closed with nothing to vote on. The board can only note it. If you have the signatures, attach them to a page that has a motion and a cost, and send it before the deadline.
This is the route this chapter teaches. The secretary's answer tells you whether ten days is enough for this meeting. The page gives the board a motion it can adopt, a cost with its source, and a smaller alternative, perhaps the worst rows only. Whether the board has the power to spend the money is in its bylaws.
A reasonable path if you have missed the agenda deadline, and it starts the conversation. The tradeoff is a month's delay, and a spoken request leaves no record unless the minutes capture it. Follow it the next day with the one page, sent to the secretary.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.