Appealing a decision
Asking for something

Appealing a decision someone has already made

Read the denial for its reason, its route and its deadline, then write to the ground the decision was made on. The letter you received governs your case.

Start here Essentials

A written decision tells you what was decided, why, where to appeal and by when. Find those four things, then answer the reason it gives. If nothing has been decided yet, you are writing a request instead: Asking a person or a business for something.

  1. Find the reason, the route and the deadline on your decision letter. Write all three at the top of a page, in the letter's own words (reading the letter).
  2. Put the deadline in your calendar today, with a reminder a week before. Count it from your letter, not from any page on this site (the deadline counter).
  3. Write one paragraph answering the stated reason. Not the whole history (writing to the stated ground).
  4. Attach only what bears on that reason, and send it by a route that leaves a record. (Sending the letter, proof of mailing, and following up)

Minimum time: one hour. Done when: your first paragraph names the decision, its date and the reason given, and says what you are asking them to do instead.

The decision letter is the instruction manual Understand

An appeal asks the body that made a decision, or the next level inside the same system, to decide it again. A complaint goes to someone else about how you were treated. The difference matters for the writing: an appeal is read by a person whose job is to check the decision against the rules they apply, so it has to talk about that decision and those rules. A complaint about rude staff, slow phone lines or a confusing form may be true and worth sending, but it belongs in a separate letter to a separate office (Writing a complaint so that it gets fixed).

The decision letter is the written notice of what was decided. Different programs call it different things: an insurer's denial, an explanation of benefits, a determination (the word Social Security's regulations use for a decision; HealthCare.gov speaks of a "final determination" from an insurer). Whatever it is called, it is the most useful document you have. Look for four things in it.

What to findWhat it looks like on the pageWhat to write at the top of your pageIf you cannot find it
The decision"Denied", "not covered", "your claim is not approved", with a date and a reference numberThe date of the letter, the reference or claim number, and what was decided, in their wordsAsk the office in writing which decision the letter records
The stated reasonA phrase such as "not medically necessary", "insufficient documentation", "outside the coverage period", often with a policy section or rule numberThe reason, quoted exactly, with any section numberAsk in writing for the reason and the rule it rests on
The routeA heading such as "Your appeal rights" or "If you disagree", with an address, a form name or a portalWhere the appeal goes and what form, if any, it has to be onCall the number on the letter, write down the date, time and name of the person, and ask for the route in writing
The deadline"Within 60 days", "within 180 days of receiving this notice", "by" a dateThe number, what it counts from (the letter's date or the day you received it), and the date it givesAsk the office in writing, and meanwhile count from the earliest date on the letter

The route is the published path an appeal has to take: the address or portal, the form if there is one, and the level it goes to. Many systems have more than one level. HealthCare.gov's appeals page describes two for a health plan: an internal appeal, which asks the plan itself to review its decision, and then an external review, the second level, which takes the decision outside the plan's own appeal process if the plan upholds it. A level's letter usually tells you about the next one (Medicare.gov says so for Medicare), so you read every letter in the chain the same way.

Each route in this chapter has a deadline. HealthCare.gov's internal appeals page says you must file an internal appeal "within 180 days (6 months) of receiving notice that your claim was denied". That is a published figure for one route. The letter you received governs your case: if it gives a different number or a different starting point, the letter and the office that sent it are the authority, and you ask them about any difference in writing.

Preference Our rule for counting: when a letter is unclear about whether the clock starts on the date printed on it or on the day you received it, count from the printed date. It gives the earlier deadline, and sending a few days early costs nothing. Write the date you received the letter on the envelope or the letter itself, and keep the envelope.

Writing to the stated ground

The stated ground is the reason the decision letter gives. It is the only reason the reviewer is checking, so it is the only reason your appeal has to answer. A letter that tells the whole history, every phone call and every frustration, makes the reviewer search for the one paragraph that matters, and sometimes they do not find it.

One sentence does most of the work. It names the decision, its date, the reference number and what you want, and it gives the reason in one clause:

I am appealing the decision of [date] denying [what was denied], [claim or reference number], and I am asking you to [the action] because [the answer to the stated reason].The decision, its date and its number tell the reader which file to open. The action tells them what a yes looks like. The reason is the stated ground, answered.

Then the rest of the letter supports that sentence and nothing else. A useful test is to put the stated reason in the middle of a blank page and ask, of each fact you were going to include, whether it makes that reason wrong, or shows that the rule was applied to the wrong facts, or shows something the decider did not have. If it does none of those, it goes in another letter or nowhere.

Stated reasonWhat answers itWhat does not answer it
"Not medically necessary"A letter from the treating doctor saying why the service was needed, in terms of the reason given; the records the doctor relied onHow long you have been a member; how much you pay in premiums; how unwell you felt
"Insufficient documentation"The missing document, named as the one they asked for, with a list of what is enclosedA second copy of everything you sent the first time, with nothing added
"Outside the coverage period" or "filed late"The dated record that shows the date they used is wrong: a postmark, a confirmation number, a dated receiptAn explanation of why you were busy
"Not a covered service" under a named sectionThe section of your own policy or plan document that you read differently, quoted with its dateA statement that other plans cover it

Preference The rows are this manual's working list, built from the reasons decision letters commonly give. They are not a rule from any program, and they say nothing about whether your answer will succeed. The plan, agency or creditor applies its own rules to what you send.

HealthCare.gov's internal appeals page says you can complete the insurer's own forms, "Or you can write to your insurer with your name, claim number, and health insurance ID number", and that you can submit additional information you want the insurer to consider, giving a letter from the doctor as its example. That is a good model for any appeal: the identifying numbers at the top, then the reason, then the supporting document that speaks to the reason.

Attach copies, and list them. A short numbered list of enclosures at the foot of the letter lets the reviewer see that nothing fell out of the envelope. Each enclosure earns its place by bearing on the stated ground. Ask for the evidence you are missing as soon as you know you need it; The evidence you need, and where to find it covers asking for a policy, a file or a record in writing, and the evidence sheet holds the dates, documents and numbers.

Send it so there is a record. The United States Postal Service's extra services page lists Certified Mail at $5.55 as of 2026-11-13, under the line "Prove you sent it." Product-specific Prices change; check them at the counter. What each kind of proof shows, and what none of them shows, is in Sending the letter, proof of mailing, and following up. If the route is a portal or a fax number, use that, and keep the confirmation.

Who may file for you

Someone else can often write or file an appeal on your behalf: a relative, a friend, a benefits counselor, a lawyer. Medicare and health plans ask for your signed permission first, other offices may too, and some programs name the form.

  • Medicare. Medicare.gov's claims, appeals and complaints page names the Authorization to Disclose Personal Health Information form, CMS-10106, with a Spanish version, as the form needed if someone else files a claim, an appeal or a complaint for you.
  • Health plans. HealthCare.gov's internal appeals page lists, among the papers to keep, any signed form if a third party files for you. Ask the plan which form it uses, and keep a copy of the signed one.
  • Everything else. Ask the office that sent the letter what it needs before someone else can act for you, and get the answer in writing. A helper who sends an appeal the office will not accept from them can cost you the deadline.

Whoever writes it, the letter still comes from the person the decision was about, names them and their reference number, and is signed in the way the office asks.

Published deadlines for common routes Go deeper

Limits

This chapter is how to write the appeal. It is not advice about whether you will win, what your rights are, or whether to get a lawyer. The deadlines below are the published ones for a handful of common routes, read on 2026-11-13. The letter you received governs your case, and where the two differ, the letter and the office that sent it are the authority. A state insurance department, an ombuds, a benefits counselor or a lawyer answers the rest.

Go deeper

These are the figures the agencies and regulations publish for six routes, with the source of each. They are here so that a reader who did not know there was a deadline learns that there usually is one, and roughly how long it tends to be. They are not a lookup for your case.

RoutePublished figureWhat it counts fromSourceYour case
Health plan, internal appeal"within 180 days (6 months)"Receiving notice that the claim was deniedHealthCare.gov, internal appeals; for group health plans the regulation, 29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i), requires plans to "Provide claimants at least 180 days following receipt of a notification"The letter you received governs your case
Health plan, external review"within 4 months"The date you receive a notice or final determination that the claim has been deniedHealthCare.gov, external reviewThe letter you received governs your case
Social Security, reconsideration"Within 60 days"The date you receive notice of the initial determination20 CFR 404.909(a)(1), at Cornell's Legal Information InstituteThe letter you received governs your case
Social Security, hearing before an administrative law judge"Within 60 days"The date you receive notice of the previous determination or decision20 CFR 404.933(b)(1), at CornellThe letter you received governs your case
Credit card, billing error notice"no later than 60 days"The date the creditor transmitted the first periodic statement showing the error; the notice has to be received by then12 CFR 1026.13(b)(1), at CornellYour statement and the creditor's billing-error disclosures govern your case
A debt a collector says you owe"only have 30 days" to ask for certain informationWhen you are contactedCFPB, when a debt collector contacts youThe collector's notice to you governs your case
MedicareNo day count on the page we readEach decision letter gives the next level's instructionsMedicare.gov, filing an appealYour decision letter is where the deadline is
Veterans AffairsNo number on the page we readThe page says options depend on time since the decisionVA decision reviews and appealsYour decision letter is where the deadline is

Notes on the rows, in the same order.

  • Health plans. The regulation behind the 180 days is a floor ("at least"), and it is the figure for group health plans. The same regulation gives a shorter floor, at least 60 days, for plans generally at 29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(2)(i), read at Cornell. Another kind of benefit plan can give a different number than a health plan. One more reason the letter governs. The regulation calls a denial an adverse benefit determination; you may see that phrase on a plan's letter.
  • External review. HealthCare.gov says standard external reviews are decided no later than 45 days after the request is received, and that where a plan does not use the process administered by the Department of Health and Human Services and charges a fee, "the charge can't be more than $25 per external review." Whether your plan's external review runs through your state or the federal process is something the plan's final letter names and your state insurance department can confirm. The letter you received governs your case.
  • Social Security. Reconsideration is the first level of appeal after an initial determination: a fresh look at the decision. The regulation's own text allows for "the extended time period if we extend the time" under its paragraph (b). We cite the regulations themselves; Social Security's letter to you, and its offices, are the authority on how they apply.
  • Credit card billing errors. A billing error is, for this purpose, a charge or credit on a card statement that you believe is wrong. This is not an appeal of a decision in the usual sense, but it is read the same way, and the regulation goes further than most: 1026.13(b) says what the notice has to contain, including enough for the creditor to identify your name and account number and, so far as possible, the type, date and amount of the error. Note the word received: the notice has to arrive within the 60 days, at the address the creditor discloses for billing errors. The shape of a letter that gets read uses this notice as its worked case.
  • Debts. The CFPB page says a collector's validation information, sent in its first communication or within five days of it, includes "the name of the creditor, the amount you owe, and how to dispute the debt". In other words, the collector's own notice tells you the route. The same page offers five sample letters and says "These sample letters are not legal advice." Whether you owe the debt is not a writing question.
  • Medicare. Medicare.gov says "Generally, there are 5 levels of appeals" and that each level's decision letter gives instructions for the next. The page we read gave no day count, so we give none. The deadline for your appeal is on your Medicare decision letter.
  • Veterans Affairs. VA's page names the routes: a Supplemental Claim, a Higher-Level Review, an appeal to the Board of Veterans' Appeals, a Clinical Appeal, and the legacy process for a Notice of Disagreement on a decision dated before February 19, 2019. It says the options depend on "how long it's been since we issued the original decision" and gives no number here. The deadline for your review is on your VA decision letter.
  • School decisions. A decision about a child's special education services has its own routes, and Learn IEP Basics covers them in When you disagree with the school. We do not restate them here.

If waiting would put your health at risk, HealthCare.gov's appeals page says urgent cases are sped up. Say in your first line that the case is urgent and why, and ask the plan, by phone and then in writing, how to request faster handling.

Close to the deadline, or past it Go deeper

Go deeper

When it is close. Send what you have before the deadline rather than a complete file after it. Say in the letter what is still coming and when you expect it, and ask the office in the same letter how it handles evidence that arrives after the appeal. Preference That is our rule, not a published one. A late appeal with a doctor's letter is rarely better than a timely one that says the doctor's letter will follow.

Asking for more time. Some routes allow an extension. Social Security's reconsideration regulation provides for one in its paragraph (b). For the other routes on this page, the sources we read do not describe one. Ask the office that sent the letter, in writing, before the deadline, with the reason, and keep the reply. Ask the authority A phone call that says "that should be fine" is not an extension until it is in writing. If you only get it by phone, write down the date, the time and the name of the person, which is the habit HealthCare.gov's internal appeals page recommends for every call about an appeal, and send a short note confirming what you were told.

When it has passed. Ask anyway, in writing. Say plainly that the deadline has passed, give the reason, and say what changed. Do not hide the date or hope the reader will not notice. Whether a late appeal can be accepted is the office's decision under its own rules, and an ombuds, a benefits counselor or your state insurance department can tell you whether there is another route.

At a second level. Preference When the first appeal is turned down and you go on to the next level, lead with what the first reviewer did not have or did not address: a new document, a fact they got wrong, a reason they gave that differs from the original letter. A second letter that repeats the first in a firmer voice gives the new reader nothing new to decide on. Quote the second decision's stated reason, the same way you quoted the first.

See it: an MRI denial, answered See it

Fictional example

Walt Osei, 61, of Tucson, Arizona, has a letter from Saguaro Health Plan. Walt, the plan and everyone below are fictional.

Known. The letter is dated October 2. It denies coverage for an MRI billed at $2,340, claim number SHP-2026-118842, and gives the reason as "not medically necessary". It has a section headed with his appeal rights and an appeals address.

Assumed. That the appeal section gives 180 days. That is Walt's assumption from HealthCare.gov's page, and he settles it by reading the section again and writing the number and its starting point at the top of his page. He also did not write down the day the letter arrived, so he counts from October 2, the earlier date.

Open. Whether his doctor will write a letter that speaks to "not medically necessary", and how soon. Settled by: his doctor's office, which Walt asks in writing. Whether the plan treats the MRI as a service already received, which decides how long the plan has to answer him (HealthCare.gov gives 30 days for a service not yet received and 60 days for one already received; the plan's own letters govern his case). Settled by: the plan. Whether his plan's external review, if he needs one, runs through Arizona or the federal process. Settled by: the plan's final letter, and Arizona's state insurance department can confirm.

His three lines, at the top of a page:

Reason: "not medically necessary" (letter of Oct 2, claim SHP-2026-118842) Route: written appeal to the address in the letter's appeal section Deadline: [the number of days the letter gives], counted from Oct 2If his letter gives 180 days, 180 calendar days from October 2 is March 31, 2027. Six months from October 2 would be April 2. He uses the earlier date.

He checks that date in the deadline counter, then sets a calendar reminder a week before it. Then his draft, ready to send when Dr. Nand's letter arrives:

Walt Osei 1408 East Ocotillo Lane Tucson, AZ 85719 520-555-0172 [the date it goes] Saguaro Health Plan Appeals Unit [the appeals address printed on the October 2 letter]Copied from the letter, not from a website. The letter's route governs. Re: Appeal of October 2, 2026 denial, claim SHP-2026-118842 Member: Walt Osei, member ID SHP-M-50318Name, claim number and member ID: the three items HealthCare.gov says to put in a written appeal. They go first so the reader can open the file. I am appealing the decision dated October 2, 2026 denying coverage for an MRI billed at $2,340, claim SHP-2026-118842, and I am asking you to reverse it and cover the MRI. The letter gives the reason as "not medically necessary."The decision, its date, the number and the action, in one sentence. The stated reason, quoted. My doctor, Dr. Priya Nand, ordered the MRI. Her enclosed letter explains why she ordered it and answers the reason your letter gives.Walt does not argue medicine himself. He points the reviewer to the person who can speak to the stated ground. Please send me a copy of the criteria or policy section you used to decide that the MRI was not medically necessary.A request, not a claim of a right. Whether the plan has to send it is a question for the plan or the state insurance department. If you need anything else to decide this appeal, please write to me at the address above or call 520-555-0172. Sincerely, Walt Osei Enclosures: 1. Copy of the October 2, 2026 denial letter 2. Letter from Dr. Priya NandTwo enclosures, both bearing on the reason. Not the premium statements, not the history of his condition, not his phone notes.

What Walt left out: three paragraphs about his years with the plan, a phone call where he was put on hold for forty minutes, and a sentence calling the decision ridiculous. The hold time may belong in a complaint. None of it answers "not medically necessary".

  • Internal appeals: HealthCare.gov's page with the 180-day figure, the plan's own clocks, what to put in a written appeal and the papers to keep.
  • External review: HealthCare.gov's page on the second level, its 4-month figure and how long a review takes.
  • 29 CFR 2560.503-1: the claims procedure regulation for employee benefit plans, read at Cornell; the 180-day floor is at (h)(3)(i).
  • Filing an appeal: Medicare.gov's page on its five levels, for a reader whose decision came from Medicare.

Practice: three lines and one paragraph Practice

Minimum: the reason, the route and the deadline written at the top of a page, the deadline in your calendar, and one paragraph that answers the stated reason. Time: about one hour, plus however long it takes to get a supporting document. Materials: your decision letter and its envelope, a calendar, the deadline counter and the evidence sheet.

  1. Read the whole letter once without a pen. Then read it again and mark the decision, the reason, the route and the deadline. Turn the page over; the appeal rights can be on the back or the last page.
  2. Write the three lines, quoting the letter's own words for the reason and the deadline.
  3. Count the deadline in the deadline counter from the earliest date the letter supports, and put it and a reminder a week before it in your calendar.
  4. Write the one sentence: I am appealing the decision of [date] denying [what], [number], and I am asking you to [action] because [reason].
  5. List what you would attach, and cross out everything that does not bear on the stated reason. Enter the rest in the evidence sheet, with the date you asked for anything you do not have yet.
  6. Read your first paragraph alone. If a stranger reading only that paragraph would know which decision, which date, which number and what you want, it is done.
Go deeper

The second-level drill. Take an old denial of your own, or invent one, and imagine the first appeal was turned down with a slightly different reason. Write the new first paragraph, quoting the new reason, and list only what is new since the first appeal. If the list is empty, that is the finding: get something new before you write.

The route check. For your own letter, find the row in Where a complaint or an appeal goes next that matches it, and compare the published route with what your letter says. Where they differ, the letter wins, and the difference is a question to put to the office in writing.

What you are writing What you are writing

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Do the reason, the route and the deadline appear at the top of your page, quoted from the letter?
  • Is the deadline in your calendar, counted from the letter, with a reminder before it?
  • Does your first paragraph name the decision, its date, its reference number and the action you want?
  • Does it quote the stated reason and answer that reason, rather than a different one?
  • Does every enclosure bear on the stated reason, and are they listed?
  • Is the route the one on the letter, and will it leave a record?

Worked example

Walt's page passes each criterion except one he cannot settle alone. His three lines are at the top, quoted. His deadline is counted from October 2 and is in his calendar with a reminder, on the condition that his letter gives 180 days, which he has checked. His first sentence names the decision, the date, the claim number and the action, and the second quotes the reason. His enclosures are two, both about the reason. The one gap is the doctor's letter, which is open until her office replies. If it is not in hand ten days before his deadline, he sends the appeal with a line saying it will follow, and asks the plan how it handles a document that arrives later.

Common mistakes

  • Answering a reason the letter did not give. If the letter says "insufficient documentation", an argument about medical need answers the wrong question. Quote the reason before you write a word about it.
  • Using a figure from a website instead of the letter. The table on this page is published figures for common routes. Your letter can say something else, and your letter governs.
  • Counting from the wrong day. "Within 60 days after the date you receive notice" and "within 60 days of the date of this letter" give different dates. Write down which one your letter uses.
  • Mixing an appeal and a complaint. Rudeness on the phone is a complaint. Put it in a separate letter if you want to send it.
  • Sending originals. Send copies, keep the originals, and keep a copy of the whole appeal as sent.
  • Waiting for the perfect file. A timely appeal that says a document will follow is usually better than a complete one that misses the date.

What is still unresolved

This chapter does not say whether your appeal should succeed, what you are entitled to, what a policy means or whether a decision was lawful. The office that made the decision applies its rules. For a health plan, your state insurance department can answer questions about your rights and the external review; for benefits, a benefits counselor or the program's ombuds; for a school decision, the routes in Learn IEP Basics' When you disagree with the school; and for anything with legal stakes, a lawyer. Where the appeal goes after a final no is listed by subject in Where a complaint or an appeal goes next, and how to send, log and follow it up is Sending the letter, proof of mailing, and following up.

Knowledge check and scenario

Your health plan's letter gives you 60 days to appeal. HealthCare.gov's page says 180 days. Which date goes in your calendar?
The one your letter gives, counted the way your letter says. The published figure tells you what the rule generally is; the letter you received governs your case. If the difference worries you, ask the plan in writing which applies, and meanwhile work to the earlier date. A state insurance department can answer questions about whether a plan's letter is right, but that is their call, not something to settle by picking the later date.
A denial says "not medically necessary". What should the first paragraph of the appeal answer, and what should it leave out?
It should name the decision, its date and number, ask for the action (reverse it and cover the service), and point to what answers medical necessity, usually the treating doctor's letter. It should leave out the history of the membership, the cost of premiums, and how the phone calls went. None of those answers the stated reason, and complaints about service go in a separate letter.
What is the difference between an appeal and a complaint, for the purpose of writing?
An appeal asks the body that decided, or the next level of the same system, to decide again, and it has to talk about the decision and the rule. A complaint goes to someone about how you were treated. Mixing them buries the stated reason under material the reviewer is not checking.
(Go deeper) Why does this chapter's table give no deadline for Medicare or VA?
Because the pages we read gave none. Medicare.gov says there are generally five levels of appeal and that each decision letter gives the next level's instructions; VA's page names the review routes and says the options depend on how long it has been since the decision, with no number. Supplying a figure from memory or another source would be guessing. The deadline is on your decision letter.
It is three weeks before the deadline Walt counted from his letter. His doctor's office says her letter will take about a month. What does he do?
This risks the whole appeal for one document. A complete file that misses the date can be refused without anyone reading the doctor's letter. Whether a late appeal is accepted is the plan's decision, not his.
This keeps him inside the date the letter gives and tells the reviewer what is coming. It does not settle whether the plan will wait for the doctor's letter before deciding; that is the plan's to say, which is why he asks in writing and logs the answer.
Reasonable, if he gets the answer in writing. A phone yes is not an extension until it is written down: he notes the date, time and name, and sends a short letter confirming what he was told. Without that, he is relying on a conversation nobody else can check.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.