The evidence you have
Before you write

The evidence you need, and where to find it

A dated list of the facts, documents and reference numbers behind your letter, with the claims you cannot support marked before anyone else finds them.

Start here Essentials

Put what you know in a table, with a date on every row, before you write a sentence. For a request to a business, that may be three rows: what you paid, when, and what went wrong.

  1. Write down every date, amount and reference number you already have, in a table. One row per thing that happened, oldest first (a date on every row).
  2. List the documents you have and where each one is. A statement, a receipt, a letter, a photo: name it, and say where you would find it tomorrow (what counts).
  3. Write the one or two facts you are missing, and who holds them. Often the other side holds them: their ledger, their policy, the itemized bill (what you are missing).
  4. Ask for the missing ones in writing, today. One short message, the reference number at the top, each document named (asking for it).

Minimum time: 30 minutes. Done when: your evidence table has a date on every row and no row that says "around". The sheets in Evidence and numbers hold it.

What counts as evidence Understand

In this manual, evidence means anything a reader other than you can check: a document, a dated record, a number, a statement made by a named person on a known date. Your memory is where evidence starts. It is not evidence until it points at something the reader can look at. Preference That is this manual's working definition for letters. It is not a legal definition, and the Limits box below says why the difference matters.

KindExamplesWhere it usually isWhat makes it usable
DatesWhen you paid, ordered, called, or received the letterBank statement, order confirmation, the letter's date line, your call notesThe date comes from a document, not from memory
AmountsThe charge, the fee, the refund you are asking forThe bill, the statement, the receipt, the ledgerThe exact figure, cents included
Reference numbersAccount, order, claim, policy, ticket, docketThe top of the bill or letter; the confirmation emailCopied from the document, character by character
The ruleA lease clause, a policy section, a return policy, a regulationYour copy of the agreement; the company's website; the letterIts number, its sentence and the document's date
The written decisionA denial letter; an email that says noYour mail or your inboxThe whole thing, with its date and its stated reason
PhotographsDamage, a meter reading, a posted signYour phoneThe date taken, and what it shows, written beside it
People you spoke withPhone calls, conversations at a counterYour own notesThe name, the date, the time and what they said, written down that day

A reference number is the number the other side uses to find your file: an account number, an order number, a claim number. It goes at the top of everything you send, because it is the first thing the reader needs and the last thing they want to look up.

Agencies that receive disputes publish their own lists of what to include, and those lists are a good default. The Federal Trade Commission's page on disputing a credit card charge says "Include your name, address, account number, and a description of the mistake." Convention That list is one agency's, for one kind of letter. HealthCare.gov's page on internal appeals says you can write to your health insurer with "your name, claim number, and health insurance ID number," and send anything else you want the insurer to consider, such as a letter from your doctor.

Limits

A document you have not read is not evidence, and a screenshot without a date is not a record. A forty-page policy you have not searched is a document, not a point in your favor. This chapter teaches how to gather what you have and list it so that a reader can check it. It does not teach what evidence proves a legal claim, or whether yours is strong. That is a question for a lawyer, or for the office that decides.

A date on every row

A record is a document made at the time, showing what happened and when, that someone else could check. The test of a record is the date. A row in your table without one is a memory with a label on it.

"Around" is not a date. "Around the 10th" in a letter invites the reader to pick the date that suits them. Find the document that fixes it: the bank statement, the email, the call log on your phone. If there truly is no document, say so in plain words: "I do not have a record of the date; it was the week of November 2." Preference An honest range reads better than a confident date you cannot show.

A screenshot shows what a screen looked like, not when. To make one a record:

  • Get a date into the frame: the page's own date, or your device's clock and date.
  • Name the file with the date you took it, such as ledger-2026-11-04.png.
  • Better still, download the statement or ledger as a PDF from the source. A downloaded statement carries its own dates and its own header.

Preference That list is our practice, not a published standard.

Send copies, keep originals. The FTC's card-dispute page says "Include copies (not originals) of receipts or other documents that support your position." Convention The original stays with you, because you may need it for the next rung, and a letter can go missing. Note in your table which copy went where and on what date.

Attach what bears on the ask. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau's complaint form caps attachments with the note "Limit: 50 pages." Product-specific That is a ceiling for one portal, not a target. A reader who has to search fifty pages for the one that matters may not find it.

Oldest first. The federal plain-language guidance on organizing information gives chronological order for process information, and a dispute is a process: this happened, then this, then this. Convention The shape of a letter carries the same order into the facts paragraph.

Fact, inference and feeling

Every sentence you plan to write is one of three things, and each is written differently.

  • A fact is something a document or a named person can show, with a date: "My rent cleared my bank on November 1."
  • An inference is a conclusion you draw from facts: "So the payment reached you before the 5th." It may be sound. It is still yours, not the document's.
  • A feeling is how it affected you: "This has been stressful."
SentenceKindWhat supports itHow to write it
"My November rent of $1,040 cleared my bank on November 1."FactThe bank statementState it, and attach the statement page
"Brookside received my rent before the 5th."InferenceThe bank date; Brookside's own ledger would settle it"My bank shows the payment cleared on November 1, so I believe it reached you before the 5th." Or ask for the ledger first.
"The fee was charged in error."Inference: the conclusion you want the reader to shareThe two rows above and the leaseOnce, after the facts, as your belief with its reason
"Brookside charges these fees to make money off tenants."Inference with nothing behind itNothing you can showLeave it out
"This has been really stressful."FeelingYour own accountOnce, if it bears on the ask; usually it does not

Even a regulation keeps the belief and the evidence apart. The federal rule on credit card billing errors, 12 CFR 1026.13(b)(3), asks the cardholder for "the reasons for the belief that a billing error exists." It asks for a belief, and for the reasons under it, as two things. That is the honest form of an inference in any letter: "I believe X, because Y," with Y pointing at a row in your table.

What you cannot evidence, you do not assert. Preference This is this manual's rule. One sentence the reader can see is unsupported gives them a reason to doubt the sentences that are supported. In a public review, an unsupported claim about a person can also carry legal risk; Praise, references and reviews covers that, and a lawyer answers it.

The feeling still has a place, which is usually one sentence and sometimes none. Tone covers where it goes and how to write it without making the reader defensive.

What you are missing, and who holds it

Most tables have a gap, and the gap is usually in someone else's files: their ledger, the policy they applied, the itemized bill, their notes of your call, your account history. Sometimes a third party holds it: your bank, your doctor's office, the shipping company.

Ask for it in writing, even when a phone call would be quicker. A written request dates the request, records exactly what you asked for, and gives you a document to point at if nothing arrives. Preference Keep the request short and separate from the dispute itself:

  1. The reference number and what this is about, in one line at the top.
  2. The documents you want, as a numbered list, each named precisely enough that a reply sending something else is plainly off target.
  3. How you want them: by email as a PDF, or by mail.
  4. The date you would like them by, and in a few words why.

The request usually goes to the gatekeeper rather than the decider, and it asks for nothing but documents. Arguing the dispute in a document request gives the reader a reason to route it to someone else. Each request goes on the Documents to ask for sheet in Evidence and numbers, with the date you asked; when the document arrives, write that date too.

A debt collector is one case where the rules say what the other side has to tell you. The CFPB's page on debt collectors says the collector's validation information, given in the first communication or "within five days of the initial communication," includes "the name of the creditor, the amount you owe," and how to dispute the debt. The same page says "you only have 30 days after you're contacted to ask for certain information." Convention That 30 days is the CFPB's general statement. The notice you received governs your case, and the collector, the CFPB or a lawyer answers questions about it. The page also offers five sample letters, with the note "These sample letters are not legal advice."

Quoting the rule that binds the reader

The rule that binds the reader is the clause, policy or regulation the decider has to follow: the lease they signed, the plan they administer, the return policy they published. Quoting it moves the letter from what you want to what they agreed to, or are required to do. Preference When there is such a rule, it is usually the strongest row in your table.

Quote it in three parts: the document's name and date, the clause or section number, and the sentence itself in quotation marks, copied exactly. Quote the version that applied on the date the thing happened. Policies change, and the date tells the reader which version you mean.

DocumentWhat to citeHow it looks in the letter
A lease or contractThe date it was signed and the section numberLease dated [date], section [number]: "[the sentence, copied exactly]"
An insurance policy or plan documentThe plan's name, the document's title, the plan year and the page or section[Plan name], [document title], [year], section [number]: "[sentence]"
A decision letterIts date, its reference number and its stated reason, in quotation marksYour letter of October 2, 2026, claim SHP-2026-118842, which gives the reason "not medically necessary"
A company's published policyThe page's title, its web address, the date you read it, and a dated copy[Policy title], read on [date] at [address]: "[sentence]"
A regulationThe citation, and the paragraph if you can find it12 CFR 1026.13(b)

Quoting a rule is not the same as saying what it means for your case. "The lease says rent is late after the 5th, and my rent cleared on the 1st" puts two facts side by side. Whether a clause means what you read it to mean, in a dispute that goes further, is a question for the office that decides or a lawyer. Ask the authority

Asking for the policy, the bill, the recording or the file Go deeper

Some documents are worth asking for by name, because the reply to a vague request is usually a summary.

What to ask forWho holds itHow to word the request
The policy or criteria appliedThe company or plan that decided"Please send the policy, criteria or guideline you applied in deciding [the decision, its date and reference number]."
An itemized billThe provider or seller"Please send an itemized bill for [date of service or order], listing each charge with its date and amount."
A call recordingThe company you called"Was my call of [date] at [time] recorded? If so, how do I request a copy?"
Your file or account historyThe company or office"Please send my account history (or claim file) for [start date] to [end date]."
A ledger with posting datesA landlord or management company"Please send my ledger showing the date each payment posted, for [months]."

Ask the authority Whether they have to send any of these is a separate question, and the answer depends on the industry and the state. The company is the first to ask; after that, the regulator for that industry, such as a state insurance department for a health plan, or a state consumer protection office. Asking does not cost you anything, and a refusal in writing is itself a record.

Fictional example

Walt Osei, 61, of Tucson, Arizona, asks his health plan for the criteria behind a denial.

Known. Saguaro Health Plan's letter dated Friday, October 2, 2026, denies the MRI of his lower back taken on September 3 and billed at $2,340, claim number SHP-2026-118842, as "not medically necessary." His doctor, Dr. Priya Nand, ordered the MRI.

Assumed. That the plan applied a written guideline to reach that reason. Walt's assumption. Settled by: the plan's answer to his request.

Open. What the guideline says, and whether his doctor's notes were in front of the reviewer. Settled by: Saguaro Health Plan, asked in writing. Whether the plan has to send what he asks for is for the plan, or a state insurance department, to say. Dr. Nand's office holds its own records of why she ordered the scan, and he can ask there too.

Saguaro Health Plan, Appeals Re: Claim SHP-2026-118842, letter dated October 2, 2026The claim number and the letter's date at the top: the two things the plan uses to find his file. Member: Walt Osei, member ID SHP-M-50318 Please send me: 1. The policy, criteria or guideline you applied in deciding that the MRI was "not medically necessary."The denial's own words, in quotation marks, so the reply has to address that reason. 2. A copy of the records the reviewer considered. Please send them by email as PDFs, or by mail to the address on file.No argument about the MRI. That belongs in the appeal, which Appealing a decision covers, and its deadline is on his letter.

Phone notes. HealthCare.gov's internal appeals page lists the papers to keep for a health plan appeal, and among them are notes from phone calls with the date, the time and the name of the person you spoke with. That is a sound standard for any call about any dispute. A page of notes for one call:

Date: 11/04/2026 Time: 10:40 AM Number called: Brookside office, 937-555-0130 Spoke with: front desk; gave first name onlyWrite what you got, even when it is incomplete. Ask for a name or an employee ID next time. I asked: why a $125 late fee was posted on November 3, and who can reverse it They said: the fee is applied automatically; the property manager can reverse fees, by the office email on my rent statements What happens next: nothing offered Reference number given: none

Preference Send a short email the same day that confirms the call: "To confirm our call at 10:40 this morning, you told me the late fee is applied automatically." It turns a conversation into a dated record the other side has seen.

A regulation read as a shopping list Go deeper

Some rules say what a letter has to contain. Read as a list, such a rule tells you what evidence to gather before you write. The clearest example in our sources is the federal billing-error rule that covers credit cards, part of Regulation Z: 12 CFR 1026.13, read at Cornell's Legal Information Institute.

Paragraph (b) defines a billing error notice as "a written notice from a consumer that" meets three conditions. Each condition turns into rows in your evidence table.

What 12 CFR 1026.13(b) saysThe evidence it calls for
(1) Is received "no later than 60 days after the creditor transmitted the first periodic statement" showing the error, at the address the creditor gives for billing errorsThe date of the first statement that shows the error; the billing-error address printed on your statement
(2) "Enable[s] the creditor to identify the consumer's name and account number"Your name as it appears on the account; the account number
(3) To the extent possible, gives your belief, the reasons for it, and "the type, date, and amount of the error"What kind of error it is; the date of the charge; the amount; the facts behind your belief

The 60 days in (b)(1) is the regulation's general rule. Your statement and card agreement govern your case, and the card issuer or the CFPB answers questions about it. The FTC's card-dispute page puts the same clock in plainer words: send the letter so it reaches the issuer within 60 days after the first bill with the error was sent to you.

The same reading works on any rule or form with a contents list: an agency's "what to include" page, a form's required fields, a lease's notice clause. Turn each item into a row, then fill the rows. The shape of a letter uses the same rule as a model for the order of the letter itself, and Complaining so it gets fixed uses it for a card dispute.

See it: a ledger with the dates filled in See it

Fictional example

Corinne Vasquez builds the evidence table for her late fee. She rents a one-bedroom apartment, Unit 2B, in Dayton, Ohio, from Brookside Management, and wants the property manager to remove a $125 late fee from account 4471.

Known. Her bank statement shows the $1,040 rent transfer clearing on Sunday, November 1, 2026. The tenant portal ledger shows the $125 fee posted on Tuesday, November 3. On Wednesday, November 4, the front desk told her by phone that the fee is automatic, and that the property manager is the person who can reverse a fee.

Assumed. That section 4 of her lease, which she remembers as saying rent is late after the 5th of the month, reads the way she remembers, in the version in force. Corinne's assumption; her copy is in a box from her move. Settled by: the lease itself, which she asks Brookside for.

Open. The date Brookside posted her November payment to her account. Settled by: Brookside's ledger, asked for in writing. Also open: the exact wording of section 4. Settled by: the lease. The full name of the person she spoke to on November 4 is open too, and she does not need it for the ask.

Her first table, from memory:

around Nov 1 paid rent bank early Nov late fee showed up screenshot last week called, "automatic"

Three rows, two "around"s, and a screenshot with no date in it. The finished table, after twenty minutes with her banking app, the portal and her phone's call log:

DateWhat happenedAmountDocument that shows itWhere it isWho I spoke with
11/01/2026November rent paid by bank transfer; cleared the same day$1,040.00Bank statement, line dated November 1Downloaded PDF of the November statement
11/03/2026Late fee posted to the ledger, account 4471$125.00Tenant portal ledgerLedger downloaded as a PDF on November 4; shows the posting date
11/04/2026Phone call to the office; told the fee is automatic, and that the property manager can reverse fees$0.00My call notes, 10:40 AMNotebook; phone's call logFront desk, first name only

The undated screenshot is gone, replaced by the ledger downloaded as a PDF, which carries its own posting date. "Last week" became 10:40 AM on November 4, from her phone's call log. The two documents she lacks go in one short request, sent on Monday, November 9, separately from her late-fee email to the property manager that day:

To: Office, Brookside Management Subject: Account 4471, Unit 2B: two documents, pleaseThe account number is how the office finds her file, so it goes in the subject line. Please send me, by email as PDFs: 1. A copy of my current lease, including the page that says when rent is late. 2. The ledger entry showing the date my November rent payment of $1,040 posted to account 4471.Each document named precisely, so a reply that sends something else is plainly off target. I would like them by Friday, November 20, before the November 23 date in my email about the November 3 late fee.A date and a reason in one sentence. The fee itself is argued in her other email, to the property manager, so it is not argued here. Corinne Vasquez Unit 2B 937-555-0114

What she left out: a neighbor told her Brookside "does this to everyone." That is an inference she cannot show, about other people's accounts, and it would give the property manager a reason to stop reading. It stays out of the table and out of the letter.

  • Using Credit Cards and Disputing Charges: the FTC's consumer page, with the agency's own list of what a dispute letter includes and its line on copies, not originals. Dated May 2022.
  • Internal appeals: HealthCare.gov's page on appealing a health plan decision, including the list of papers to keep and what to put in a written appeal.
  • What should I do when a debt collector contacts me?: the CFPB's page on validation information, with five sample letters for asking a collector for more information.
  • Submit a complaint: the CFPB's complaint form, which takes attachments up to 50 pages and asks first whether you have contacted the company.

Practice: the evidence table Practice

Minimum: the Facts sheet with a date on every row, and one written request for whatever is missing. Time: 30 to 45 minutes, plus the wait for a reply. Materials: the documents you have, your bank or card statements, your email and your phone's call log, and the sheets in Evidence and numbers.

  1. Gather everything into one folder, paper or digital. Originals stay in it; copies go out.
  2. Fill the Reference numbers sheet first, copied from the documents, not typed from memory.
  3. Add one row per event to the Facts sheet, oldest first. Take each date from a document. Where a row can only say "around", write in the Document column which document would fix it, and add that document to the list to ask for.
  4. Fill Document and Where it is for every row. If the answer is "a screenshot", check that it has a date in it; if not, get the dated version from the source.
  5. Mark each sentence you plan to write as fact, inference or feeling. Every fact points at a row. Every inference gets a "because" that points at a row. A claim with no row comes out.
  6. Fill the Documents to ask for sheet and send the request today. Write the date you asked.
Go deeper

Notes for every call. For each call you have made about this, write a page of notes in the form above: date, time, number, who, what you asked, what they said, what happens next, any reference number. Send a short confirming email for the ones that matter.

The shopping list. If an agency, a form or a regulation lists what your letter has to contain, write each item as a row in your table and check that every one is filled.

The rule row. If a lease clause, a policy section or a published policy binds the reader, add it as its own row: the document's date, the section number and the sentence in quotation marks.

What you are writing What you are writing

Check your work Check your work

Criteria

  • Does every row in the table have a date taken from a document, and does no row say "around"?
  • Does every row name the document that shows it and where that document is?
  • Is every reference number copied from the document itself?
  • Is every missing document on the list to ask for, with who holds it and the date you asked?
  • Is every sentence you plan to write a fact with a row, an inference with a "because", or a feeling you chose to include?
  • Are you sending copies and keeping the originals?

Worked example

Corinne's finished table has three rows, each with a date from a document: the bank statement, the downloaded ledger and her phone's call log. Each row names its document and where it is. Her two missing items, the lease and the payment posting date, are on the request sent on November 9, with November 20 as the date she would like them by. Her plan has one inference, that Brookside received the rent before the 5th, and she wrote it as a belief with the bank date as its reason. The neighbor's remark is not in the table.

Common mistakes

  • Dates from memory. The bank, the inbox and the call log usually have the real date.
  • An undated screenshot as the only copy of a ledger, a chat or a web page.
  • Sending originals. Keep them; send copies.
  • Citing a document you have not read. "Per my policy" with no section number tells the reader you have not found the sentence.
  • Writing an inference as a fact, such as "you received my payment on time," when only their ledger shows that.
  • Arguing the dispute in a request for documents, which sends the request to the wrong desk.
  • Attaching everything. The reader looks for the one page that matters and may not find it.

What is still unresolved

A complete table does not say whether your case is strong, or what a clause means if the dispute goes further; the office that decides, a regulator or a lawyer answers that. It does not decide what you ask for, which is What you are asking for, or how the facts sit in the letter, which is The shape of a letter. If you are answering a written decision, Appealing a decision covers which evidence bears on the stated reason, and the deadline on your letter governs when it goes.

Knowledge check and scenario

Corinne has a screenshot of the late fee on the portal, with no date in it. Is it a record?
Not on its own. It shows what the screen looked like, not when. A version with the page's own date or the device's date in the frame is better, and the ledger downloaded as a PDF from the portal is better still, because it carries its own posting dates.
Is "Brookside received my rent before the 5th" a fact or an inference, and how should Corinne write it?
An inference. Her bank statement shows the rent cleared on November 1, which is a fact. When Brookside posted it is in Brookside's ledger. She can write it as a belief with its reason, "My bank shows the payment cleared on November 1, so I believe it reached you before the 5th," or ask for the ledger and replace the inference with a fact.
Why send copies rather than originals?
The FTC's card-dispute page says to include copies, not originals. You keep the original because you may need it for the next rung, and because a letter can go missing. Note which copy went where and when.
(Go deeper) How does 12 CFR 1026.13(b) work as a shopping list for evidence?
It says a billing error notice has to reach the creditor within the time it sets, identify your name and account number, and as far as possible give your belief, your reasons, and the type, date and amount of the error. Each of those is a row to fill before you write: the statement date, the billing-error address, the account number, the charge, its date and amount, and the facts behind your belief. Your own statement and card agreement govern the deadline in your case.
Your health plan denied a claim. You believe the reviewer did not look at your doctor's notes, and you want to open your appeal with "Your reviewer clearly did not read my file."
It is an inference you cannot show, about what another person did, and it puts the reviewer's competence at the center instead of the stated reason. One unsupported sentence also gives the reader a reason to doubt the supported ones.
This turns a suspicion into a request for the record, which either confirms it or replaces it with a fact. It does not settle the appeal, and it does not stop the clock: the deadline on your denial letter governs, so the request for records and the appeal may need to run side by side.
Safer than the accusation, and a fair choice if time is short. The tradeoff is that you do not find out what the reviewer had, which may be exactly the gap your appeal needs to fill.

Checklist

Records your learning only; it is not a qualification.